Casey's is a friendly and clean place with good food and helpful staff. Customers appreciate the quick service and the clean, well-maintained location, including spotless bathrooms. The pizza is enjoyed by many, and the pellet ice is a favorite. A standout moment was witnessing a kind cashier, possibly named Hunter, show patience and kindness toward young girls paying with a piggy bank and change, creating a positive experience. The bakery items, especially the brownies, are highly praised as being fresh and delicious. Overall, visitors have a great experience at Casey's, highlighting the friendly staff, cleanliness, tasty food, and welcoming atmosphere.
Shout out to the store with the donuts for Valentine’s Day and the Valentine’s Day pizza that’s awesome. Thanks for the person that took the time out to do it.
January 2025
Casey's Cheese Pizza!!!
When your food isn't good @ Fuji Hibachi in Muncie.....you stop @ Casey's Yorktown on the way home for take home!!!
Thank you for having Cheese pizza ready!!
April 2024
Love the pizza, chicken sammies, and pork tenderloins. Alot better quality than most gas stations. Love
