Casey's is a popular pizza spot that offers a variety of pizza options, including slices and whole pizzas. Customers enjoy ordering both simple and customized pizzas, often praising the pizza's freshness and taste when made well. Some reviews highlight the quality of the pizza, calling it "amazing" and "the best," especially when freshly made and hot out of the oven. However, experiences can vary. One customer was disappointed with a less fresh pizza that lacked sauce and had an extra topping, feeling it was not worth the price. Another reviewer mentioned that ordering a slice from the warmer is a great way to enjoy the pizza, and they prefer Casey's over other places despite bumpy parking. Additionally, staff are appreciated for their patience, especially when making last-minute changes over the phone. Overall, Casey's is loved for its delicious pizza, though occasional issues with freshness and order accuracy can happen.
Ordered pizza online they were super busy. One kid in the kitchen with a ton of pizza orders. He did a great job.
August 2025
Added something to my order after the fact over phone after placing order on app. Call was choppy, but the person I talked to was incredibly patient. Got me the thing I forgot to throw on to the order, even though he had to do a lil BS to get it figured out.
January 2023
If you've only bought a slice from the warmer you are seriously missing out. Order a pizza whole pizza u won't be disappointed.
