-
January 2024 by KYLE KEITHLEY
The pizza staff at this store are all rock stars. They have exceeded expectations with a smile and not just once or twice. I've given them numerous opportunities to screw up. They don't. Please keep up the great work ?.
-
December 2023 by Luke Griesel
I found a hair that was not my own in my pizza. The people in the kitchen need to wear gloves and hairnets but everytime I go in they aren't being worn. Everything else is great.
-
October 2023 by Jorgi McNamara
Just got a pizza from Casey's in Humboldt, IA, and there was something really wrong with it. The underside was soaking wet, and the toppings did not stick to the pizza. You could lift them up like a blanket off the crust. The top just slid right off. Plus, the taste was funky. We threw it away and made ham sandwiches.
-
March 2023 by Krystal
One of my favorite caseys stops! Staff is always friendly.
-
February 2023 by Eric B.
I've stopped at this Casey's several times over the years during travel from Ames to Spirit Lake (or Estherville) and back. It's roughly half way and serves as a convenient rest room, snack, and gas stop. It's at a major intersection, which means easy access and exit back to whatever your main road might be. It's also a busy place, which means being patient as the trusty Casey clerks server their customers. This is also an area where it's best to be as invisible as possible, both in word and deed. An example of the later was during COVID where Gayle's and my wearing of masks elicited dirty looks and snide comments from a number of bare faced fellow citizens. Of course, no one was going to tell them what to do, but I guess we were somehow entitled to their opinion.....
-
October 2022 by Bruce Watnem
Very good pizza ?
-
July 2022 by Cindy R
Love the new bbq brisket pizza! Hope they keep it. Order was fresh and super hot. Delivery was on time. Friendly service.
-
November 2021 by Purely Potential
What can I say we are very lucky to have a Casey’s here in Humboldt which gives us another decent pizza option. The Casey’s rewards program is a must have giving you money back on store items with every purchase. Plus you got to give a company credit that started in Iowa. Really I think their pizza is 3rd best in Humboldt and 1st best in bone-in Buffalo wings. I wish they’d have 91 here.
-
January 2021 by Allie Drew
First I usually love eating at Casey's it has been my favorite place to eat at for a long time but today it was the worst experience ever. I ordered some food to be picked up around 12:30, I got there and asked the guy behind the counter if my food was done yet, he then told me to hold on a minute and that he would check. Instead of actually checking though he just handed me the food that was sitting in the warmer (which is gross because you don't actually know how long it was there) I dealt with it because they seemed a little busy but when i got home and actually checked my food it was gross and burnt and hard.
-
December 2020 by Jebediah Bishop
Stopped in for lunch and something to drink at lunchtime. Had a very wide variety of stuff in the warmers, food was fresh and very good. Staff members were friendly and efficient, looked like they were stocking shelves or something and everyone seemed to be working hard. Definitely going above and beyond your average Casey's store .
-
December 2020 by Jerry Depue
Older store but still have the basics.
-
November 2020 by George Laurie
Standard Casey's store chain clean and fast service in and out lickity split
-
October 2020 by Laura Rees
Very friendly people in a lovely small town
-
October 2020 by Chris Johnson
Caseys is high priced with mediocre food but always consistent
-
October 2020 by Pacific PM
While the pizza is usually good here, I've had a few bad experiences with the no contact delivery. There has been more than one time where the food was late. At first it was just a few minutes, which turned into roughly half an hour, and once even over 1 or 2 hours late. This last time the pizza was messed up even though the receipt was right, and when called and asked for a redo, I was charged again for them to fix their mistake. And they asked for the original pizza back when 1. They never said they wanted it back over the phone and 2. During this pandemic I would expect no restaurant or eating place to ask for food they already delivered back, as I feel that would be a risk (especially since in order to know the pizza was wrong I had to open the box, exposing the food even if I didn't touch it) and while I have not been in contact with anyone I know of that is confirmed to have a case, if they were to ask this of someone else who did and weren't being cautious, then the box and pizza could be a risk. Also, if they just planned on throwing away the pizza, then that's just a waste, along with the fact they already charged me twice (which they should not have since they were fixing their mistake), they have no reason to ask for the messed up pizza back. Not ordering from this Casey's for a long time.
