Casey's in Lake Mills is a convenient location offering quality fuel, household essentials, and groceries. It is known for its great pizza, featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and the freshest toppings, including a praised beef brisket pizza. The staff are very nice and provide helpful service. While the pizza and employees are excellent, the automated phone ordering system can sometimes lead to delays, as orders may not be ready at the promised time. Overall, it is a clean, well-organized, and popular stop in the area.
Always a pleasure stopping in. Sierra is always a pleasure to take with and very helpful.
December 2023
It’s not the employees fault at all, but the automated phone ordering needs work. I showed up at the precise time my order was supposed to be done and it was literally just being thrown into the oven. Nothing beats talking to the person making my pizza. They know when it’s going to be done. Great pizza and employees!
August 2023
My family ordered a lot of pizza from this Casey's and the staff were very nice to me. They even offered to take the pizzas out to my car for me!The pizzas were so good. The beef brisket pizza was surprisingly good (it was my first time trying it).
