-
August 2025 by Larry
Very amazing, the bathrooms were clean and there was fresh pizza, staff is also very friendly, I love coming here!
-
August 2025 by Marissa Holland
I ordered my food at 3:54 and it said it should’ve arrived at 4:50 and this is the one in Muscatine on university Street or whatever and I’ve been waiting and so I’m not really happy with how long it’s taking. I don’t think I’ll ever order Casey’s again.
-
July 2025 by Luke dalbey
Excellent management and amazing staff, all around 5 stars
-
June 2025 by Cindy Trumbull
We ordered a Taco Pizza. Looks like we got the bottom of bag of chips. Crushed and pushed down into the pizza. Crust was not cooked thru...very disappointed, nothing like the quality when you walk in.
-
October 2024 by Kaitlyn Paustian
Worst caseys ever. 8 am on a week day and there is no hot food and the 2 employees are just standing in the back while the cashier also has a line full of ppl trying to get to work. I would be ashamed to be that manager. 10/17/24
-
April 2024 by RuffianAce
Very good food and excellent service had an interaction with an employee named Jazmin she was very wonderful in getting my food to me in a timely and efficient manner and the food was amazing definitely recommend this location to anyone looking for good fast food.
-
December 2023 by Glen Maylone
Stopped in a few times this week. It was hit or miss. Either really great friendly staff with the food being good, or don't want to be here attitude with food that probably was in the warmer way to long. When I am back in the Midwest to visit I usually look forward to seeing a Casey's.
-
December 2023 by David Lake
Always gotta stop for a slice of pepperoni piZZa.
-
October 2023 by Rudiger Monty
Ordered an olive pizza last night and when I went to pick it up they hadn't made it. When I asked why they said they weren't sure if that's what I wanted because most people get meat. My friend had just been a severe car accident and this was his favorite dish and I was bringing it to him for the first solid he could have. The employee made a sparky remark that I should have picked up my phone when she called. It had died. We got into an argument after she inisited everyone gets meat on cusom pizzas and I was asked to leave. Very unprofessional.
-
October 2023 by Brendan Sealey
Ordered an olive pizza last night and when I went to pick it up they hadn't made it. When I asked why they said they weren't sure if that's what I wanted because most people get meat. My friend had just been a severe car accident and this was his favorite dish and I was bringing it to him for the first solid he could have. The employee made a sparky remark that I should have picked up my phone when she called. It had died. We got into an argument after she inisited everyone gets meat on cusom pizzas and I was asked to leave. Very unprofessional.
-
June 2023 by Mike G.
Worst Caseys experience in my life. I called to order pizzas for carry out. I was scolded by the lady on the phone for asking for pizzas! I was told if I wanted 6 pizzas or more I had to call 24 hours in advance. I explained that I didn’t need the pizzas for almost two hours. Still scolded and told to call 24 hours in advance. “Famous for pizza?” Yeah right! The Caseys in Columbus Junction is way better! Very virtuous and easy to work with. I highly recommend staying away from this Caseys.
-
September 2022 by Yolanda Trevino
Didn’t honor my free pizza when they messed up my order cause I used a free pizza coupon specifically said “won’t honor your coupon cause coupons are for guest and my kitchen manager said she didn’t mess up your order”
-
August 2022 by Glo Girod
I don't think I've ever given a one rating. But this girl, this girl was hungry!The gas station itself might be okay. But if you're hungry, and it's 5:30 on a Saturday night, don't expect to get anything from the deli area. They're way too busy to make you a sub and apparently there is something wrong with the sandwich warmer and so you would have to order that also. And they are just way too busy to deal with someone standing in front of them.
-
March 2022 by Juliette Esperanza
The food and staff are fine but the bathroom was awful! Very messy and it smelled absolutely terrible, it looked like it hadnt been cleaned in a year!
-
September 2021 by Jordan Wetzel
Really slow check out processs in the afternoons, spend almost half my lunch break standing in line. Need more cashiers.
