Casey's at 205 S Main St New Sharon IA has the best pizza featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese and only the freshest pizza toppings. The place also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks and a variety of household essentials and groceries. People can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels. The service is fast and the people are amazing, extremely nice and always clean. The cashier was nice and the people get you fast. Parking can difficult with only maybe 15 spots and the place was packed. The help is always.
Whoever was making pizza here at this Casey’s (I believe they said his name was Jarod, but I don’t know for sure) is a rockstar. Bro knows how to make pizza. I wish Jarod worked at every Casey’s I ever visit so I can have his pizza.
March 2025
Casey's is the most reliable gas and food place I know
March 2023
Place was packed. Parking was a pain. Cashier was nice. I didn't have food here.
Parking: Maybe 15 spots to park. Very difficult to find open parking
