-
September 2025 by Shawn D
The best caseys I know staff and food wise.
-
July 2025 by Kayla Valentine
Don’t pay for extra toppings on a pizza. You won’t get it. In fact you’ll get less than the normal amount. And you won’t get anything you paid extra for. 🤦🏼♀️ guess next time I want pizza I’ll go to Carroll and get something actually good for 1/2 the price. Oh and did I mention they charged me $20 TWICE on top of the other $18 I spent in there somehow. I bought 2 waters and pizza. Almost $60. Most expensive and worse deal ever. 😵💫
-
January 2025 by Melissa Dopheide
It's just a super small Casey's. The employees are all right but the selection itself inside the store is terrible.
-
December 2023 by L L Hupp
I'm putting in a review to balance all of the disgruntled 1 star ratings. This Casey's has been here for decades and provides a valuable service to this small town. I've always had good experiences with the pizza and donuts here. It's as good as any other Casey's out there.
-
December 2023 by Laura Hupp
I'm putting in a review to balance all of the disgruntled 1 star ratings. This Casey's has been here for decades and provides a valuable service to this small town. I've always had good experiences with the pizza and donuts here. It's as good as any other Casey's out there.
-
December 2022 by Alex Teeples
Would give zero stars if I could they never stock thier shelves always have to go searching and waiting, cold drinks never stoked always buying warm drinks always closed for no reason, worst business I have ever experienced
-
October 2022 by Timothy Chance
Smaller store less options great
-
May 2022 by Alexa Anthony
Got ignored completely when I went in by the cashier. But she helped the 3 people infront of me. Won't be coming back. Rude.
-
October 2021 by Connie Scrivner
First time since Covid that we have ordered a pizza. Normally great pizza. Things have gone down hill a bit but still ok. Sign on door noting "Masks Required" is ignored by Kitchen staff preparing food without a mask!! Adult customer inside store is not wearing a mask either.
-
September 2021 by Matt Halstead
Good customer service. The workers are friendly and efficient for getting customers purchases completed. Would recommend.
-
September 2021 by Gina Lynn
There was a little black wire. In. My cheese sticks
-
August 2021 by Dave Forkner
There was a little black wire. In. My cheese sticks
-
October 2020 by Mr H
Good customer service. The workers are friendly and efficient for getting customers purchases completed. Would recommend.
-
September 2019 by Blackfire
We got food poisoning from pizza last night. Me and friend are both losing work over it.
-
September 2019 by abc 123
We got food poisoning from pizza last night. Me and friend are both losing work over it.
