Casey's in Sidney, IA, located at 901 Indiana St, offers the best pizza made with scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. In addition to pizza, there are appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials. Customers can also fill up their gas tanks with quality fuels. Although the parking is limited, the service is highly praised. Reviewers appreciate the staff for going above and beyond, especially during challenging times. Overall, Casey's is strongly recommended as a great place to visit for food and convenience.
Whoever made the breakfast pizza on 4/17/26, give them a raise! It was the best Casey's pizza I've ever had. I travel for work, so I'm in a different state every day. Thank you for breakfast!
October 2023
Parking: It's a very small establishment 10 vehicles in the driveway would be way too many so therefore others have to park along the streets and around the buildings and on the side of the street
March 2023
This place is awesome! Nothing negative to say about this location. All I can really say to do justice to this is you must go here and try this place for your self. Fully recommend.
