Casey's in Storm Lake, IA, located at 207 E Milwaukee Ave, offers excellent pizza delivery and pickup with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The menu includes appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. Customers can also fill up their gas tanks with quality fuels. While the selection is great, some reviews mention that the atmosphere has declined, with a few staff members appearing unfriendly. However, there are positive moments, such as personalized notes on pizza boxes that brighten customers' days. Overall, Casey's aims to provide what customers need, despite some inconsistencies in service.
Cashier guy was very friendly and the store was clean
February 2026
Only bought fuel at the pump. fuel prices were not listed/ working on the pumps so it was a guessing game for fuel prices.
November 2023
This place is great it has almost everything you need the only downside is sometimes I know people may have bad days, but it always feels good to feel welcome when you go inside a store there were a couple of workers that looked at you like I hate being here, make your purchase and leave.
