Casey's is a place many visit daily, offering pizza, appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, groceries, and household essentials, along with quality fuels. The pizza features made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. Many find the pizza always good, and there is often hot food available in the warmers. The business is considered a fortunate lifeline for the rural community. Reviews on the food are mixed. Some call it good, while others state the pizza can be incredibly greasy and the rest of the food is just okay. A common point is that the food and other items are often seen as overpriced, with the highest prices around. The staff receives praise for being great, kind, polite, pleasant, friendly, and doing their best. However, some note they can lack courtesy, never saying thank you, leaving loyal customers feeling unappreciated. Issues with stock, like sauces being unavailable for months and then charged for, are also mentioned. Keeping the floor and parking lot clean can be difficult with the community's traffic.
I know Casey's is supposed to be known for pizza but the other day I got an Italian salad from there and it was one of the best salads I've ever had
March 2025
Love this place. It’s perfect for this small community. The employees treat each other like family and they know most of their customers by their first names.
January 2023
The staff that work here are great and pizza is always good and most of time there is always something in the warmers! Always polite
