Casey's is a convenient stop for gas, cigarettes, drinks, and snacks including warm food and pre-made food. Customers can order pizza or pick up a slice, as well as subs, wraps, donuts, and muffins. The pizza is frequently described as awesome. The subs also receive high praise for their soft, fresh bread that melts in the mouth, leading some to prefer it over other sandwich chains. However, the experience can be inconsistent. While often clean and with pleasant staff, there are frequent frustrations. Register issues are common, sometimes making the location cash-only and preventing customers from earning rewards points on gas. This forces some to allow extra time for their stop in case they must go elsewhere. Service can also be slow, especially late at night. Specific problems like a non-working pop machine are noted. One location in particular has generated serious complaints about harassment that have gone unaddressed, making some customers avoid it entirely.
I would love to give this location 5 stars, but they never NEVER have take out orders ready at the time the app says they'll be ready. When you show up at the time specified, the order hasn't even begun to be made, let alone cooked and boxed.
May 2026
Best service station pizza ever!! Great rewards program!!
April 2026
It was a Casey's... Drinks and pizza and gas oh my. But seriously it was one of the nicer/ cleaner ones I've been to in some time.
