Historic Boone Tavern Hotel and Restaurant features a beautiful dining experience at its Crafted restaurant. Guests enjoy a warm ambiance, excellent hospitality, and delicious farm-to-table meals. The spoon bread served with fresh butter is a highlight, and the menu offers reasonably priced options like the flavorful Marry-me-chicken, perfect for couples. Breakfast is also praised for its quality, and the waitstaff is noted for being attentive and professional. The restaurant is celebrated for its seasonal, scratch cooking, and diners appreciate the inviting lobby areas for gathering with friends. While some diners experienced minor issues, such as incorrect orders or specific entrees lacking flavor, the overall experience remains positive. The dessert, especially the bread pudding with caramel bourbon glaze, receives high praise. With its commitment to supporting Berea College students, this local gem stands out as a fine dining choice in Madison County. Overall, visitors look forward to returning for another enjoyable meal in this historic setting.
Enjoyed an excellent dinner here—-everything was perfect. Also had breakfast here twice and it was delicious. Wonderful waitstaff.
January 2026
Crafted served me and my wife the best dessert I have ever eaten in my 30-odd years of life. The waitress was informed, poised, and extremely professional. 1.) Try the bread pudding with caramel bourbon glaze. 2.) Ask the wait staff for recommendations. They know their stuff.
December 2025
Of the six diners, one received an incorrect order, and one entree was relatively tasteless (butternut squash gnocchi). Our service, both at the bar and at the table, was very good, and, of course, the ambience is inviting and pleasant. Even with the snafus with the two meals, it was an excellent evening. We will definitely... read full comment
