-
April 2024 by Shan Maynard
First time there. Food was good and the waitress was good.
-
April 2024 by Richard Glover
Sat down and ordered drinks rather quickly. We didn't want the buffet so were perusing the menu. We weren't in a hurry so we're pretty relaxed waiting for Stacie, or server,, to help those who had arrived before us. But, when customers 2 tables in front of us had gotten their drinks and we're eating (because they got the ever popular biffet) we dropped a fiver for the drinks and skedaddled. Stacie was actually walking out the door to go across the hall when we were leaving. Didn't say a word...Options are limited in town,but we headed over to Cracker Barrel...
-
April 2024 by Jack Zimmer
Food was delicious for a more than fair price. Would suggest giving it a try over the Cracker Barrel down the street. Much more of a local feel and homestyle cooking.
-
April 2024 by Matthew Guin
This place was an unexpected gem. My family of four came in late on a Friday night after visiting the Caves and happily ate our fill of the delicious home cooking. The catfish was extraordinary and the banana pudding was more than up to this Carolina boy's standards. I can not recommend this place enough!
-
April 2024 by Tina Tomlinson
I was hopeful after doing a 2 hr cave tour at mammoth cave that the food would be good southern cooking. The restaurant was not clean. Tables were dirty when we walked in. Service was slow. Food was just okay. With that said, they do have a help wanted sign up and are looking for cooks and dishwashers ASAP.Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly family atmosphere.
-
April 2024 by Bev Mi
Food was great, as was the service. Coming from Michigan, was excited to see soup beans and cornbread on the menu as a side.The chicken breasts, patty melt and grilled cheese were all great. So are the prices.
-
April 2024 by Will
Very welcoming staff all the food we had was good.
-
April 2024 by David Sean
Great hole in the wall for breakfast…Not sure what the deal was with the “non salty/in water country ham”
-
March 2024 by JT JT
Pretty bad. I would definitely go somewhere else.
-
March 2024 by Mir Ma
Great people are working there, but the place is gross and the smell is terrible. Food is home style but I cannot say I would want to try it again.
-
March 2024 by John Litzau
Food is family style and delicious. Great service and hospitality.
-
March 2024 by Corey Hack
Has been a great place over the years but the experience last time was very shocking. We were there for an hour or so for a family event by the back door and literally every 5 minutes or less multiple employees would go outside and smoke weed. The smell as they opened the door and walked by was extremely overpowering and it ruined our appetites. They would also come right back in and immediately just start touching food and dishes and then back for another toke. Major turn off. Drug test your employees. Fire the potheads.
-
March 2024 by John Sims
Well priced home cooked food and a good buffet
-
March 2024 by Ornery Antics
Very small buffet. The food was good, but a few of it was cold. The atmosphere was old and sticky. The employees were great!
-
March 2024 by Local to Cave City
We are local and eat at Watermill pretty often. It is one of the few places that I will actually eat catfish. On 3/24/24 we went there and there was catfish and baked home on the buffet. We sat down and a waitress came over to take our drink order. She was nice and even asked if I wanted lemon in my unsweet tea. However once she returned with our drinks we never saw her again except for waiting on other customers. She never even brought our check. My husband went to the buffet to get some ham and they were out. A few minutes later I went up and they were putting in a big pan of fresh ham. I got a couple pieces for him and 1 for me. When I got back to the table the ham was frozen. I was getting really upset already because of our lack of service so I went to another waitress and asked for a manager. She said they did not have one. Another waitress came over and as I was explaining the situation the 2nd waitress huffed, rolled her eyes said oh my god and walked off. I was getting MAD by this point. A super nice older lady that was working came over and asked what was going on. When I told her she apologized several times and only charged us for 1 buffet. Which was greatly appreciated. She was the only professional there. We won't be going back or recommending Watermill anymore.
