-
February 2024 by Charvon Wilks
I accidentally ordered the wrong topping on my pizza so I called to get it changed but was told no because it was in the oven. I’ve been in the pizza industry for years so I know that’s a small problem to fix.
-
November 2023 by Kevin Degler
My wife and I just ordered a pizza and it taste like it's a day old. There was virtually no sauce on the pizza and the dough tasted stale. I will have to say this was the worst pizza I have ever had.
-
October 2023 by Deborah H.
Good selection able to buy multiple items at good prices enjoy the variety of food options always available easy to order or pick up
-
October 2023 by Ian E.
They have screwed up orders too many times. I won't be reccomending them to anyone. They aren't as good as they could be.
-
September 2023 by Alanna C.
The people that work at this store are always so friendly and helpful. They take time to ensure our order is correct everytime we order. I'm glad they put a store closer to us that we can just pick up on our way home from a long day at work.
-
September 2023 by Katie Fain
The dough was raw. Wasted $15 on a small pizza I couldn’t even
-
June 2023 by Nicholas Cox
I ordered a 14" stuffed crust epic pizza, and while it did have plenty of toppings and such, the crust was literally paper thin. It was very floppy and disgusting, and even without toppings (most fell off because it just was so floppy), it couldn't hold it's own weight. I ended up throwing the pizza away except the stuffed crust. Will not be ordering again
-
April 2023 by Joseph Lindemuth
Ordered online and everything went swimmingly
-
March 2023 by P 1
The best papa John’s in town! Word up! Hats off to all employees! Thank you!!!
-
March 2023 by Don Honaker
Want much of a Papa fan before but I've been eating here close to a year now. While every pizza hasn't been great, it's been very above average overall. The pizza I got tonight was one of the best. Sometimes they miss extra add-ons but they won't mind fixing it if they do. Friendly, fast, and above average.
-
December 2022 by Beth R.
Went to pick up my pizza upon arrival was told the pizza was accidentally taken by a new driver. Said the driver could bring it back but would probably be cold. So offered to remake ya sure that's fine. I know you shouldn't expect a discount or free but to then wait again was kinda ridiculous. Pizza wasn't bad though.
-
September 2022 by Brittany Wright
If you look at all the reviews of the other Papa Johns they are horrible because the Papa Johns here in Lexington are terrible EXCEPT this one… this was my first time at this location and my pizza was SOOOO GOOD! Cooked well done just the way I like it! I know for now on I’ll be coming to this location when I crave pizza from Papa John’s!
-
September 2022 by Rachael K.
Great pizza! No problems! I have no idea why this papa john's was previously rated only 1 star, this is quite possibly the GREATEST pizza I've ever laid eyes upon!!
-
September 2022 by Jonathan Frick
Best pizza I've had in a long time.Dominoes on Clays mill should send their cooks here to learn how to make a pizza!
-
July 2022 by NailedByaSpike
I’ve never had an issue until tonight. I guess because I used my reward so the Quality of the pizza didn’t mean as much obviously due to one slice having almost no cheese on it at all and the lovely hair in the corner of the box. I paid for three extra orders of pepper Cheaneys and was spoke to as if I was a child when I was told there’s four in each order you have 10….. you do the math. Really disgusting way to drop the ball Papa John’s