-
September 2023 by Gary S.
Food is cold on the very expensive breakfast buffet. Want toast? Wonder bread white only. I will say the coffee was decent but the food is not worth the price. Avoid.
-
June 2023 by Emanuele Grossi
The continental breakfast buffet is embarrassing, the tasteless and overcooked scrambled “eggs” seem to have been made by mixing some sort of powder with water. Bacon tastes like paper with salt. All this for a whopping $20/person. A 1 star rating is generous.
-
April 2023 by Maggie M.
I've read all of the low reviews but we had a very different experience with the breakfast buffet. There were 5 of us staying at the hotel and we ate there three mornings in a row. My husband and I basically ate free because of the credits as Hilton gold members. The food was fresh and tasty. As a vegan, I stuck to bagels with peanut butter, oatmeal, fruit and breakfast potatoes (charged for the continental breakfast). I do wish they had a non dairy creamer option like soy or oat milk. Everyone else had the eggs, biscuits and gravy, sausage and bacon, cereal, grits, etc. (charged the full buffet price). Plenty of choices. The waitresses were helpful and pleasant. Rhonda was especially fun. As a hotel guest it was more than fine. Convenient and good.
-
January 2023 by Lynisha Smith
Pretty decent
-
November 2022 by Michael Johnson
Love Gatsbys the atmosphere was great. Me and my family definitely enjoyed ourselves there. The guys/women/ that was playing the piano ? was awesome. I definitely will be returning real soon.
-
November 2022 by Phillip Lindsey
Love Gatsbys the atmosphere was great. Me and my family definitely enjoyed ourselves there. The guys/women/ that was playing the piano ? was awesome. I definitely will be returning real soon.
-
July 2022 by Ed S.
Stayed at the Seelbach and ate the breakfast offered to Honors members. It was low grade dog food. The eggs were powered scrambled eggs, biscuits and gravy had no flavor. Potatoes were over seasoned. Bread box had fruit flies in it. And the staff hovered over us like we were going to steal the silverware, very creepy. We didn't eat here the rest of our stay- we paid to eat out. This place should be shut down
-
July 2022 by Omar Moore
The kick back is still worth the stay!!!
-
July 2022 by Aunt Krust
Overpriced complete joke. Our Hilton Diamond credit won't even cover this expanded Hampton Inn bfast ...and by expanded I mean they serve more than one meat on a Sunday.
-
June 2022 by Mike F.
Thought it would be the standard, quality Hilton breakfast this morning, but oh no. Buffett only. No problem. No breakfast tea. Eggs smelled like fish. And the sausage was burned to black. They need to overhaul what they are doing here.
-
March 2022 by Kyle S.
I'm not sure how two spaces separated by a single door can be so different. The lobby of the Seelbach is ornate, classical, and inspired. Through the door into Gatsby's on 4th and all of that is blindingly stripped away and a simple restaurant with a buffet on portable tables is all that's left. This could be literally anywhere. It was not what I expected given that it bears the name of the character that the hotel inspired, one who is wealthy, entertaining, and a fixture of American literature. No one is going to be writing a book based on this place. White walls with sparse decoration. Some interesting sconces. Its plain. Its boring. But hey, not everything has to inspire a novel, right? We visited for breakfast, not knowing it was a buffet. We probably would have kept looking had it not been so cold, but for $20 a person, it should be OK. It certainly wasn't great, but it was OK. Service, especially for a buffet, is remarkably attentive. There's not a lot for them to do, but the two women working were well-dressed, friendly, and helpful. Food was... hmmm... So, there's not a wide selection. There are a couple of tables with what is essentially an expanded continental breakfast on one and some hot options on the other. I passed on the cereal and oatmeal and went straight for the other. The eggs seemed like they came from powdered supply, the biscuits were definitely thaw and heat, the gravy was a good consistency but lacked flavor. The sausage, bacon and home fries all had good flavor! The beverage station has a selection of a couple of juices, black coffee and decaf, water, and three types of black tea and decaf. Gatsby's is a good option if you're on an expense account and need a quick meal at your hotel before heading out.
-
February 2022 by Bridget Lewis
So incredibly pleased with our morning buffet dining service! All staff were extremely informative, helpful, and congenial! Food was fresh, promptly maintained, and delicious! Seating is comfortable and spacious!
-
December 2021 by James S.
I have had the free Continental breakfast at many hotels that exceeded what was offered for breakfast here for $19.95. We should be getting real eggs (and not the fake egg product stuff that comes in a plastic vat) for $19.95. Do we not deserve this at least? Everything was gross, except of course for the boxed cereals, which you really can't mess up. All the food was very sad looking and not fresh. Baby and wife wouldn't eat anything. J. graham cafe down the street is much better if you're looking for food prepared by actual humans and not pre-prepared, microwaved, Faux-food. Such a disappointment considering the historic nature of the hotel. I bet for the majority of the hotel's history they served excellent food. Sadly not anymore. Please get your act together, if only out of respect for this hotel.
-
August 2021 by Alma H.
This is a totally underwhelming place. The breakfast buffet at $19.95 is a joke. Eggs are not fresh. Bacon is greasy. Fruit (apples and oranges) are uncut. The oatmeal tastes as if cooked days ago. Water is served in a small plastic glass. Gatsby's does not serve lunch. Dinner is not worth talking about other than that you would be well advised to skip it. This place doesn't even merit one star. Forget it. Go elsewhere. Anywhere but here.
-
June 2021 by Jordan Weiss
Omelet was greasy, terrible coffee. Avoid
