-
March 2024 by D Friese
Second time here in 10 days. The baked lasagna was good and the place smelled amazing. Two things though: the music was a little loud and interfered with conversation. And our waitress smelled so heavily of coconut body lotion that it took away from the experience when she was near.
-
March 2024 by arcane “anonymity” ollivander
Call before you go if you want the dinner buffet. They will close it more than an hour before the restaurant closes with no warning.
-
March 2024 by Cayce L
relaxed , nice dining in area, kid area with small ball pit, gaming arcade, u are able to make reservations for groups or parties. good food, salad bar, pasta bar, pizza and dessert pizza bar. family and kid friendly. good service. clean , If you haven't ever been here its worth checking out.
-
February 2024 by Harrison Boyd
Service was excellent, and the food was
-
February 2024 by Amber Jetton
We hosted a birthday party here for our 2 year old and had a great experience!
-
February 2024 by Ranelle Rigney
Was part of a large group, 16-17 people. The service was excellent. One server took care of us, and she was efficient and very pleasant. The food was good, and there were plenty of options with pizza, pasta, salads, and sandwiches at great prices. I had spaghetti with marinara and requested some vegetables on top. The request was honored at no extra cost. We were in a very generic meeting room. I remember, as a graduate of Murray State University, when Pagliai's was in a building downtown that offered more character. The present location is just not the same. Nevertheless, still same great food and service.Vegetarian options: Paglisi's is not a vegetarian or vegan restaurant. However, as a plantbased eater I had more options than the ubiquitous black bean burger. A vegetarian would have many selections. What would make it great for a plant based eater is the option of vegan cheese.
-
February 2024 by Garrett Todd
Excellent Real cheese pizzas and pastas. The buffet was wonderful and the kids enjoyed it.
-
February 2024 by DR R
No pizza 20 minutes after opening then only 2 pepperoni. Then out.! Then one cheese then a few pieces left then none then a pepperoni. Salad bar must be from the night before. Brown lettuce, tomatoes soft and wrinkled, other vegetables are old looking. This is ridiculous!! Paid and left!!!
-
December 2023 by Deneshia
I've been eating at paglias for over 20 years. My favorite is the lasagna. Ordered tonight and the lasagna sauce has been changed. Very disappointing. I do not like it and could not eat it. Got a refund from doordash.
-
December 2023 by Cari H.
Absolutely the best thin crust pizza I've ever had and I don't ever eat thin crust, so that says a lot about me. Always great service and food!
-
December 2023 by Renee Bolen
Best pizza in Murray hands down. Love their spaghetti too!
-
December 2023 by Abby B.
So bad I hat this place I had to go back agin! And the buffet tasted like a four year old dipper mixing with 50 year old poop I hate it and you will not believe this I saw the rat that made fun of me it said "grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr" it was so scary I cried
-
November 2023 by Carl Arnold
Thou been here several times , best pizza in town . Just the kids that take ur order , or somewhere in the chain they get my crust wrong and have to remake.
-
November 2023 by VR Davinci
FINALLY! The BEST pizza we’ve had since moving to Kentucky. Service staff is always smiling. Reminds me of an old school Americana pizza joint. We love this place!!Kid-friendliness: TWO arcades.
-
October 2023 by Marc Hays
I've always liked pagliais pizza been eating there since the 70
