-
February 2024 by Jeremy Hollinger
Always amazing! A must for Saturday
-
February 2024 by Andreas Chronis
Don’t come here if you think all restaurants should be run like a Wendy’s. Incredibly hardworking establishment, putting more care into pizza (and bread) making than most. Truly excellent pizza, absolutely perfect crust and delicious toppings. The most beautiful outdoor and indoor dining areas and very kind service. I challenge you to find a better pizza anywhere on the east coast. I know I’ve tried. Buy their bread immediately if you see it in local shops. It’s killer.
-
December 2023 by Jason W.
The pizza and other bread products are amazing. I always feel lucky when I can either pick up a pizza or dine on the farm which has the most amazing garden and overall vibe--they sell out quickly. Fortunately. You can find the baked goods at various cafes and occasionally at the Blue Hill Co-op.
-
December 2023 by Redtigerlily
Unbelievably delicious! Well worth the
-
November 2023 by Jess
Always a wonderful
-
November 2023 by Mike M.
To put it simply: Tinderhearth is about great food, great atmosphere & great people!!!
-
October 2023 by Aine C.
Yes, I traveled 40 miles round trip for great pizza on a recent trip to Ellsworth. Check out Tinder Hearth Bakery and you will agree with me, whole-heartedly! Yes, I'm one of the folks who read about this place in the NYT--and let me tell you, that write-up was dead on. Ok, enough words; head on over to Tinder Hearth Bakery and meet their nice crew and eat some yummy pizza in a chill, relaxed atmosphere. Yum!
-
October 2023 by Jessica Marquardt
I live in the area and this still felt like driving to the middle of nowhere. But the yard and barn are adorable and the pizza is really good. Oyr son loved playing on the sandbox while we ate delicious pizza.
-
October 2023 by Joseph Duggan
Very warm welcome by staff! Great space! Fabulous breads, scones, and other pastries. The cappuccino was very disappointing - liquid only, minimal foam. If Tinder Hearth masters the cappuccino I would rate 5 stars. I will definitely go back. I just will not get a cappuccino.
-
October 2023 by Geoff Reynolds
Tinder Hearth has the best bread and pastries anywhere, and everyone is so friendly. Definitely worth the trip
-
October 2023 by Jen Simmons
Cinnamon bun delicious! Spiced apple croissant delicious! Bought a large selection and everything was very well made! Barn is neat, seating is charming. Definitely stop and enjoy!
-
October 2023 by Rose Wallace
Always a special evening. A magical garden with the best pizza. We wish we could get in weekly but with the hustle and bustle of summer we usually only get to once per year and it's always memorable. A favorite that our kids remember year after year.
-
October 2023 by Jason Martin
This place is totally worth the drive!! It won the best restaurant for 2023 by The NY Times and this is why we chose it.From the moment we drove onto the lot (limited parking), to walking up to the romantic lit barns/field, to finding a table that felt like home, to eating a gormet salad and scrumptious pizza, We found a GEM!!You’ve got to make this a MUST-STOP while in the area. Totally worth the drive!!
-
October 2023 by Michael G.
Significantly overpriced for what it was. We had one pizza, a beer , and a wine. I won't mention how much we actually paid, but it was 40% more than we would have paid at some other pizza place. I guess it must have been the ambiance upcharge. The food was good but not "over the moon" delicious.
-
September 2023 by FiveThirteen A.
Pizza was so good that as we pulled out of the driveway onto a dark Island Maine street and saw an upside down pizza box in the middle of the two lane road that had clearly been placed on top of the the car of the person to leave before us and forgotten and fell off.. one of us jumped out and grabbed it to eat later. Sorry to whomever didn't have their leftovers. We ate it. 10/10 the best street pizza in the game. Would have fought a raccoon for it.
