Dyer's Variety Store is a beloved neighborhood spot described as a diamond in the rough. The staff is consistently noted as great, awesome, friendly, nice, and welcoming with warm personalities. Reviewers love the food, calling it unbelievable, delicious, good, and always hot. Specific favorites include the best steak fries in the area, incredible pepperoni pizza, cheeseburgers, coffee, homemade whoopie pies, and a great Italian sandwich on soft bread. The store offers a variety of products and is praised for its fair prices.