-
October 2024 by W W
They were friendly, but I didn’t think they offered fair prices for coins that I tried to sell. I understand stores have to make a profit. And 50 cents on the dollar is normal for a resale business… but more for pawn shops. But the offers I received were less on high value items. Selling normal American eagles and morgans was better through national services or wholesalers.
-
October 2024 by Laura Christensen
These guys are absolute treasures!! They offered me more than I asked for my gold coins and they couldn’t have been any more kind, courteous, and helpful. I won’t go to any other dealer from now on whenever I need to cash in on my coin collection. They’re funny chaps, too! I wish I was there under happier circumstances. Parting with any of my collection is a challenge, but sadly necessary for me at the moment. However, they made the whole process easy and painless and they kept me laughing. They’re honest, decent folks and truly delightful. I can’t recommend them enough. Thank you guys so much!! ?
-
March 2024 by Ayi N. Henley
I brought 11 grams of 24k coins, and they offered me $60. First I agree because I think they would give me $60/gram, but he said no. That is the total for all the coins. LOL. I don't know what they are thinking about. Maybe they think I am idiot or what. I brought it to Smyth Jewelers then they offered me $630. I hope they stop treating people like an idiot.
-
February 2024 by Thomas Stickney
Went in to sell some bullion and coins, in and out quickly, they were polite, and got a very fair price. Highly recommend.
-
February 2024 by MISTER T
I went to Certified Rarities after finding a gold coin on a parking lot. The money they offered me would’ve paid my mortgage for a year. The gentleman who appraised it then advised me to lock it up and hold onto it . I went there to see if it was real gold. It was .999 pure gold. After talking with them, I started buying gold and silver from APMEX. I trust them wholly.
-
February 2024 by JEROME T
I went to Certified Rarities after finding a gold coin on a parking lot. The money they offered me would’ve paid my mortgage for a year. The gentleman who appraised it then advised me to lock it up and hold onto it . I went there to see if it was real gold. It was .999 pure gold. After talking with them, I started buying gold and silver from APMEX. I trust them wholly.
-
April 2023 by gstaniii
Always have a good experience- new owner is very customer oriented and inventory is good. This is my go-to coin shop.
-
March 2023 by William S.
It was a while since I last visited and I was surprised to see a totally remodeled shop. There was a quality selection of coins on display and I had a nice conversation with Charles who introduced me to Rick (Brian has retired). I am looking forward to revisiting soon to treasure hunt. My selling experience was smooth and quite satisfactory (as usual).
-
February 2023 by Rance Burger
Certified Rarities provided me with prompt and courteous service. They were honest and confirmed what I thought to be a fair value of the coins they evaluated for me. I felt I was treated fairly and given a fair offer for the coins I brought in. I will gladly visit this shop in the future.
-
December 2022 by Venus
Do not go here. First of all I came here and the lady had an attitude. I'm a customer and she was ignorant. Second of all she didn't even look at my coins. She only wanted to give me $25 for all my coins. And she had the audacity to say "We'll we have alot of them anyway so... "in a rude way. And "no one else is going to buy them." Again it's no point of being jealous or rude to customers. Lastly, Good News it took a few days. But I sold one of my coins for $500. So this means she was just trying to low ball me.
-
November 2022 by Jessica G
The gentleman at the counter, I believe he was the owner, was very upfront and honest about pricing. He bought a set of Peace Dollars and Morgan Dollars from me, and even showed me exactly what he was going to be charging for them on resale. He offered the best price on the whole city and was very professional. I certainly recommend him and his business to anyone who has coins to sell or wants to buy antique coins or gold or silver.
-
September 2022 by Urban Storm
Great place. Great staff. Even better customer service....
-
July 2022 by Randy Jachman
Very honest and very fair
-
April 2022 by Kris Belschner
I've bought and sold here for several years because they are friendly, knowledgeable, fairly priced, and the selection is great.
-
April 2022 by Stephen Maged
Top of the line coin shop, recommend them , friendly and fair
