Mill Creek Farms is a wonderful store and a farmers market worth stopping at. It is a quaint reflection of the past with everything, including fresh produce, bulk foods, groceries, pies, jams, salsa, and Smith Island cakes. A food truck is often next to the market, serving delicious sandwiches. The pit beef sandwich is excellent, smokey, flavorful, and super fresh. The fries are perfectly golden and crispy, and the fried fish is also delicious. For dessert, the fudge is the best, staying smooth and creamy, and the ice cream and milk shake are a refreshing treat. They also have beautiful flowers.
I go here every summer when open. The best thing you can buy is the Smith Island cakes. You can tell produce is refrigerated and put out everyday. Not the freshes idea. Also, eggs, bacon, cheese, milk is either expired or close to it. I keep hoping it gets better because they are super nice people.
July 2026
When on Rt 50, stop. Great country store. A must see and buy when traveling. 👍👍
April 2026
The French apple pie from here was amazing! 🥧 I got it while passing through the area, definitely worth stopping here. Tons of goodies!
