Gardner Coins & Cards is a family-owned and operated business with over 50 years of experience in buying and selling gold, silver, and other valuable collectibles. Customers can explore their extensive selection of sports cards, luxury watches, and precious metal bars, as well as have their jewelry and bullion appraised and purchased. While some reviews mention the owner's idiosyncratic behavior, the overall sentiment is positive. Customers report receiving fair and competitive prices, with a focus on satisfaction and a customer satisfaction guarantee. The staff is described as personable and helpful, even assisting with small tasks like providing coins for the parking meter. Despite a few negative reviews, the majority of customers seem to have had a pleasant experience at Gardner Coins & Cards, praising the fair pricing, knowledgeable staff, and unique inventory. The business is recommended for those interested in buying, selling, or exploring a wide range of collectibles and precious metals.
Was in a couple months ago and was treated very fair. Would deal with them again for sure.
January 2026
I’ve been in here a handful of times the past few months to buy/sell silver and have been treated very fairly by the owner Joe, his daughter, and her husband. Not sure where the negative publicity is coming from.
November 2025
The man who runs the store is a great guy I just started my football collection and prices are very good compared to others
