Nantucket Windmill Auto Rental is a highly recommended car rental service known for its friendly and professional staff. Customers consistently praise the easy check-in and drop-off process, making the rental experience smooth and hassle-free. The service provided by the staff, particularly at the rental desk, is noted for being exceptionally kind and helpful. The company offers a variety of cars, including well-maintained options like the Toyota 4Runner, all in clean condition and at reasonable prices. Many reviews highlight the convenience of reserving and pricing rentals online, as well as the helpful transportation services that include pick-up and drop-off at the ferry. Regular customers appreciate the competitive pricing and the friendly service, often mentioning that staff promptly address any questions or changes to reservations. Overall, Nantucket Windmill Auto Rental is seen as a reliable choice for anyone needing a rental car on the island, with a reputation for excellent service and a good selection of vehicles.
We walked in right off the flight and they were able to accommodate us, which was amazing. Highly recommend! Also saved $1,388 by cancelling our previous reservation at another nearby rental agency. They are onsite at the airport and very convenient. Would definitely use them again.
July 2026
We rented a mini-van from the week and it was great. It was a hybrid so it was excellent since we didn’t put on a lot of miles. Windmill is a great value especially when compared to Hertz.
May 2026
We have rented cars from Windmill several times with great experiences. The vehicles are low mileage, very clean and more importantly, the team is friendly and the service is great. The team will help getting between the ferry and your car if you plan ahead to coordinate with them.
