New Salem General Store is a charming and welcoming place that offers a variety of delicious baked goods, including the best muffins and pastries in America. Visitors often praise the friendly and kind staff, making it a beautiful spot to enjoy homemade and handmade gifts, as well as great coffee and danishes made in-house. The store features a well-stocked deli with tasty sandwiches like the corned beef Reuben and hearty chili that is flavorful but not spicy. It provides a perfect stop for drinks, snacks, grocery basics, and interesting local items, including local hard cider. Whether passing through or exploring locally, customers find it to be a delightful place worth visiting again, appreciating its cozy atmosphere and quality food offerings.
Awesome little general store with both groceries and ready to eat sandwiches.
July 2026
Great spot with a fantastic selection and genuinely friendly staff. They have everything from freshly made sandwiches and local jams to handmade crafts and plenty of other unique finds. Impressive selection of gluten free and vegan options available as well.
July 2025
Always good food, treats, and the staff is so friendly.
