-
July 2024 by Ta C
Unfortunately, we had a not so pleasant employee. She seemed irritated that we asked for something from the chocolate side and mumbled to us with a look of disdain. The chocolate and ice cream were both good.
-
July 2024 by Kelly Buxton
horrible rude service
-
June 2024 by Ronald Landefeld
We were on the island at the end of May 2024 to cycle around it.
Shortly before the ferry left, we enjoyed the best ice cream we've had in a long time.
-
June 2024 by Taylor Braaten
Bad customer service and unorganized line, people cutting the line and being helped ahead of me. Staff were not very nice or helpful, ended up leaving without buying my goodies out of frustration after waiting 15 mins. Quite a few people left behind me too.
-
May 2024 by Emily Pan
The iconic lobster ice cream exceeded my expectations—generous chunks of fresh-tasting lobster mixed into a creamy and rich but not overly sweet butter base made for a unique and delicious treat!
-
April 2024 by Nick N
Be prepared to spend $1,000,000 when you cash out. Quality was ehh.
-
November 2023 by Sandra Souza
Lobster Ice Cream....enough said!
-
November 2023 by Andrew G.
No better place on Martha's Vineyard for ice cream and chocolates. Don't miss it. Helpful staff and a fun atmosphere.
-
September 2023 by Gail C.
Wonderful ice cream flavors and generous servings. This store is part of the MV tradition. Try the lobster ice cream for a different treat. Sit outside on a bench and watch the world walk by. Or you might watch others standing in line. Yes, there is a line but servers are fast and it moves quickly.
-
September 2023 by Jane C.
Mmmmmhh!! hmmmmm!! Oh my goodness! I have been going here since they opened... forever ago! BEST HOMEMADE ICE CREAM!! Prices seem high UNTIL you receive this giant cone or cup! Dairy free options along with soft serve, also dairy free. They even have some gelato, if you're lucky! The candy selection is insane- too many options to list here. I have upgraded to a small sundae- one scoop of one flavor and half a scoop of another OR just have a scoop and a half of the same - the ice cream is creamy, not heavy and smooth. My favorite candy is the dark chocolate caramels - YUM! I know the owners and one of them was my camp counselor (found that out last year) - the other owner - love her dogs! Enjoy!
-
August 2023 by Nicholas Miles
yummy! there’s even a lobster ice cream!
-
August 2023 by Jim G.
Excellent ice cream. I had the lobster and black raspberry. The lobster is unique, little bits of lobster in butter base. Very unusual and works much better than I thought it could be.
-
August 2023 by W C.
We've actually already been here twice on this trip, and had a much better experience tonight than the first time, so we're landing on four stars. The first time that we were here a couple days ago, our kiddo got a bubble gum ice cream that was practically melting off the cone and getting everywhere, and this is SUCH a pet peeve! RECOMMEND THE CUP in a scenario like that. It's ice cream serving 101! That first time one of us also got a cherry chip that was way too hard/almost crunchy, but the scoop of mud pie was pretty amazing. Butter pecan is fine. Service wasn't the most efficient. Tonight, we headed there with some fam after tiring of the illumination crowds, and while the line was out the door, we have to say that the manager was running a Tight Ship corralling all the humanity. Everything moved quickly and they had a bunch of people working and that just shows good business savvy. This time our daughter got the chocolate PB cookie dough in a cup and we all had a more pleasant experience. The mint chip was off (texture and flavor) but the triple chocolate was killer. Also, the black forest deserves a special mention. We don't like this place as much as the Ice Cream Candy Bazaar in Edgartown, but it's certainly better than Mad Martha's (which now officially sucks--do not go!) or Big Dipper. Until we find something better in OB, we guess that this'll have to be the place.
-
August 2023 by Jane Baker
Every time we go to Ben and Bill's we get great service and delicious ice cream and chocolates. The sea salt caramels will change your life.
-
July 2023 by Stephanie Sanchez
Large variety and the Lobster flavor is available. It has actual pieces of lobster meat:)