-
March 2024 by Cindy Nguyen
I just wanted to say that the spicy seafood soup is one of the best soups I've ever had in my whole life, if not one of the best foods. That soup lives rent free in my head. We finished every single drop. Order the soup.
-
October 2023 by Tracy Moore
The butternut squash ravioli was to die for!
-
September 2023 by Megan B
Sooo good ! Huge portion's , and real deal italian food served w love ❤️
-
August 2023 by Nate Landers
I have been coming to Martha’s Vineyard for over 15 years and we have religiously ate at Jimmy Sea. The food is usually pretty good, however over the past three years, including today, the manager has treated me rudely. Tonight I went to the bar to order takeout and was told they are no longer accepting orders only to see her taking orders from “other” people. I have noticed how she treats white customers is vastly different than black. She is rude, and occasionally will yell at you if you don’t order quickly. As much as I love Italian food, I will not spend another dollar in this horrible establishment.
-
August 2023 by Le Lani Hines
I come here all the time and generally love it but this year the quality is not as good as it has been. The cream garlic used to be bursting with garlic but not anymore. I have been disappointed twice this summer so it is not a fluke. They must have a new chef. The portions are still large but not as large as they were and I didn't even want my leftovers.
-
August 2023 by Kim Scott
Bartender took care of us and she was amazing which made our 1st time experience more special. Food was delicious and plentiful.
-
August 2023 by Taylor Hopp
They really deserve all the stars because this was the BEST pasta I have had! Huge servings, fresh food, delicious flavor.
-
August 2023 by Bari Cooper
One of our favorite spots on the Vineyard. The salad needed help (salt, pepper and parmesan cheese) but my entree was delicious. I got the lobster and fettuccine (or linguini) special, served with the creamy garlic sauce. Yum! The roasted garlic app was yummy, but also needed some salt for it to pop.
-
August 2023 by Katherine Marshall
Every year we go to the vineyard this is on our list to go to. We always show up at 5 right when they open because it can get busy. The chicken hazel is my favorite dish. You know when you heat up leftover pasta and there’s a TON of oil at the bottom? I re-heated my leftovers twice NO oil and it tastes the same as when I got it in the restaurant. I also ordered takeout for the first time here. I had asked for extra sauce. They gave me an extra side of sauce in a container no charge. Best service. Best food, hands down. If they’re looking to open another location please consider Hingham harbor!
-
July 2023 by Robert Metro
Giant portion. Pasta cooked to perfection. Unbelievable sauce. 10 shrimp!! There's literally no negatives here other than you will need to carry your leftovers to the car. Stop in and enjoy a wonderful and filling pasta dish. Definitely one of the best spots on the island.
-
July 2023 by hayley brunner
The food is worth it. We almost didn’t go because of the pics from the inside but we had some of the best pasta we have ever had. Service is a little slow but that didn’t bother us. We were just enjoying our time. Get the garlic for the bread and the carbonara is fantastic. They also had some shrimp and chicken almost vodka sauce pasta that were both fantastic.
-
July 2023 by T C
Always a treat to dine here. Service was excellent and top notch too. i would recommend fixing the nice outdoor sign you have, the frame has seen better days.
-
June 2023 by SalR5
Amazing dinner! This quaint little place is off the main street. Be prepared to stand in line as no reservations are accepted. We happened upon it during a walk and returned just after 5 and were able to get a table. Service was excellent, great wine and the pasta is amazing. Huge portions so best to share. One of my favorite places to dine during a two week trip!
-
May 2023 by karen pyra
Great place, good atmosphere and food
-
May 2023 by Kristina Lukic
Faith was amazing server food was great and I will come again for sure!
