-
April 2024 by Valek
At Goodnight Fatty, the atmosphere is cozy, and they offer sweet treats, including their signature 'fatty' cookie. Additionally, they offer a Sunday breakfast option. However, some might find the fatty a tad pricey, at $4 each or $10 for a flight of three. Flavors change weekly, and while some, like the Cosmic Brownie, are delicious, others, like the Carrot Cake, may disappoint. I visited on a Sunday around 4 pm and didn't have to wait in line. The staff was friendly, and my order came quickly. Credit cards accepted.
-
April 2024 by Tabitha Wolford
Amazing place! Quality food, l had the peanut butter cookie and chocolate ice cream and it was delicious.
-
March 2024 by NPC
It’s a weird concept but pretty cool at the same time. Cookies are fun and really good but the vegan chocolate soft serve is absolutely insane. Oh and parking is a little nuts. Good luck with that.
-
March 2024 by Sharlene P.
THEE best!! We stopped by after our visit to the Witch Museum and this gem is located across the street. We tried the Milky Way cookie with vanilla soft serve. FRICKIN delicious, the cookie was baked to perfection, warm and paired nicely with the ice cream. We also got the Carrot Cake, also FRICKIN delicious and baked to perfection. The center was filled with a nice dollop of vanilla frosting and tasted just like a slice of carrot cake. We devoured them and unfortunately didn't snap a photo. Big shoutout to Dylan and Amanda for the great service!!:) 10/10 highly recommend!!
-
March 2024 by Holly
| Went Oct 2022 | Best cookies I’ve had, I was seriously so sad I was only able to get them once during my visit. If you love sweets, this stop is a must! I liked their iced coffee too.
-
February 2024 by William Kucmierowski (Brimstone)
Goodnight Fatty is one of the most visits in Salem - Pick up a flight of their three flavors of the day for $10 and enjoy the warm deliciousness of tasty cookie love! ? Highly recommended for the snacky people looking for a sugar fix!
-
February 2024 by Demetri P.
Cool little shop! Cookies were on point and even better the next day! Will definitely be back!
-
February 2024 by Melissa I.
Delicious desserts in a fun, inviting atmosphere. Service was quick and easy, and the packaging made it easy to carry back to our Airbnb.
-
February 2024 by Cathleen Carroll
Cookies were fantastic. We could smell them as we walked by and knew we had to stop. The workers are hustling, taking orders, making fresh batches of cookies, boxing up orders and doing the ice cream. Cookies were flavorful, fresh and still warm. Would recommend.
-
February 2024 by Krystina Steck
Always the best cookies! Depending on the time, it can be a long wait, but totally worth it!
-
February 2024 by Gloria L.
Wow, these cookies are definitely worth trying if you're in Salem! They only have certain flavors each day and they are definitely made fresh to order because the smell of the cookies just permeates once you walk inside this shop. But these cookies were great and they were also huge! I love the unique flavors they had and thought they were all really good in the three pack we got.
-
January 2024 by Melissa Plant
Best cookies I ever ate !!!
-
January 2024 by Jordan M.
Sooooooo yummy. Great cookies; somehow they made an indulgent cookie that is not too sweet and not too big. It is just right. They put crumble cookies to shame! Friendly staff who clearly loved the cookies as much as we did.
-
January 2024 by Brad Dufton
LOVE THIS PLACE! Their Savory and Sweet are out of this world! Do yourself a huge favor and go here now!Their "Savory" is a flavorful, pretzel-esque ball, filled with delicious egg, cheese, and red pepper. I have to stop myself from eating more than one.Their "Sweet" is a creative take on a Cinnamon Roll, complete icing, and mouth watering!Each and every time my family has entered through their door, we've always been greeted with a friendly and genuine "Hello!", from a staff member.They have tables available for sitting outside and often times, lawn games to enjoy as well.
-
January 2024 by Nate
Love everything about this shop. Cookies were an absolute delight.
