Sterling Rare Coin & Collectibles is a brick and mortar coin store specializing in the buying and selling of United States coins and currency. In addition to U.S. coins and currency, they also buy foreign coins and foreign currency, comic books, sports cards, gold and silver jewelry, diamonds, and pocket watches. The reviews emphasize the store's knowledgeable staff, fair pricing, and positive customer experiences. Customers praise the proprietor, Matt, for his expertise and willingness to take the time to explain the valuation of each coin. Many note that they felt they received a very fair offer for their items. The store is described as professional, knowledgeable, and personable, with a great selection of collector's coins. Customers who brought in jewelry also had a positive experience, noting that they received the expected value for their items, and in one case, even more than anticipated. The reviews highlight the store's reputation for honesty and fairness, making it a recommended destination for those looking to sell or purchase collectibles.
Tom is very knowledgeable and pleasant to work with. He explained so much to my husband and I. Best customer service around. I don't feel like I was taken advantage of at all.
June 2025
Based on the positive reviews we made an appointment to bring in ~100 coins. Matt was a pleasure to do business with. He explained his reasoning behind the valuation of each coin. He didn’t rush and we accepted what we felt was a very fair offer.
March 2025
Matt is super knowledgeable. I learn something new and interesting with each passing minute spent in the store. Great selection of collectors coins.
