-
June 2025 by Kevin
Small town hardware with significant house-building, and home remodel supplies.
Have been restoring historical homes for past 10 years and have used this company based on their customer service.
Since writing the above, have been working on a house built 200 years ago, and deserving of fine hardware and select wood.
Cottle’s has it, and if not they’ll order and deliver. And let’s not forget those small items that nobody has..Cottle’s has ‘em.
Check them out.
-
May 2025 by Steven Fischer
Contrary to their website, THEY ARE CLOSED ON SATURDAY.
-
September 2022 by Gene H.
Without a doubt some of the nicest people with whom you would ever want to interact. Fair prices, combined with a helpful, knowledgeable - and always smiling - staff. Carl in Custom Millwork is the best. So very helpful and willing to do what is needed to help with projects. My "go to" place for any lumber/woodworking needs.
-
September 2022 by Christine Towle
Cottle's may cost more, however, the service, knowledge base of the staff, and convenience is worth it, in my opinion. They deserve our business as locals. See how much help you get at Home Depot then tell me if the extra cost is worth it or not.
-
September 2022 by Sam S
All the employees are super friendly and helpful. I found all items in stock and readily available. Island pricing is about twice that of the mainland.
-
June 2022 by Jocelyn C.
Such helpful and friendly service and staff. Despite being super busy, employees were there to help.
-
May 2022 by Carla Miller
Found everything I needed and when I asked for help finding something they were very helpful
-
March 2022 by Sam Sullivan
All the employees are super friendly and helpful. I found all items in stock and readily available. Island pricing is about twice that of the mainland.
-
January 2022 by Mike Perry
Best for all your needs
-
October 2021 by Christine elwoT
Cottle's may cost more, however, the service, knowledge base of the staff, and convenience is worth it, in my opinion. They deserve our business as locals. See how much help you get at Home Depot then tell me if the extra cost is worth it or not.
-
October 2021 by Josh Dunn
I called ahead and they lied to me. Went there and they didnt have what they said
-
October 2021 by Greg S.
Called to speak with their custom woodworker. He said he didn't have time to take on my project...much less to eve speak about it. I tried to explain how small my need was and he didn't have time to discuss it. He talked over me not allowing me to even ask if there's someone else on the island he could refer me to. Perhaps if he's so busy, he shouldn't take phone calls because he surely doesn't put forth a good impression of the company as a whole.
-
August 2021 by Anyone Youwantittobe
Ordered small carpentry cutting job on a Friday that was to be completed per store employee’s own quotation on Monday. On Tuesday I phoned and received RUDE, unnecessary response from Carl who said I was slowing him down by taking my call. As if three cuts was slowing him down! Not someone to give sharp tools to! Pathetic. I’d say go elsewhere. This is not the kind of employee I would have on my team.
-
July 2021 by Super Muñeco Zuñiga
Very convenient ?
-
April 2021 by David Fournier
Great people
