Jewelry Stores near West Tisbury, MA

15 locations found near West Tisbury
View Map

“I recently purchases two necklaces and three pairs of earrings from Sioux Eagle, and I LOVE them!! The jewelry is beautiful, well-made, and unique. And Sioux Eagle herself was very accommodating, considering that her showroom is NOT WHEELCHAIR-ACCESSIBLE...but she was happy to have me pull my vehicle right up to the front of the building on her lawn, and to bring items out to me. It was easy to make an appointment with her to view items, and her showroom was actually quite easy to find, given that it's located in a residential area on one of the back roads of West Tisbury (no longer on Main Street in Vineyard Haven, sadly). In the case of one necklace and earring set I purchased, they were made custom for me: I had admired one of the necklaces she had on display, but I prefer yellow gold to silver around my neck...so she remade the necklace with yellow-gold-filled chain, as per my request! She worked quickly, and on impulse, made matching earrings, which she presented to me as well...of course I bought them, too! Sioux Eagle's jewelry isn't cheap in price, but it's also not cheap in quality, and it's handmade by her with high-calibre stones and findings. If you're looking for a gift for yourself or a loved one who loves unique, feminine jewelry, this is a great place to shop!”

4.4 Superb8 Reviews

“Permanent jewelry! Got a forever bracelet with them, they took me as a walk in, the entire staff was extremely friendly and I walked out with a beautiful new silver bracelet! Prices were normal for the service. ?”

4.9 Superb51 Reviews

“We come here whenever we're in MV, a nice local business with great chocolate. They have a variety of items like chocolate covered oreos, pretzels, non parels, bark, fudge, and more! The woman who owns it makes it herself. Cute shop.”

4.7 Superb32 Reviews

“Wow, what a fun place - so many great items to look at from art prints, rugs, antiques, knickknacks and everything in-between. Perfect place for a little gift shopping and/or retail therapy, the prices are also very reasonable especially for being on island! Definitely worth a stop in!”

4.9 Superb7 Reviews

“Gary and I have a wonderful working relationship! I truly appreciate his thorough & detailed work ethic. I recommend "Mardells Gifts & Jewelry" to everyone looking for great caring people.Thank you,Bruce Wallace - Camelot Payments ?”

4.7 Superb15 Reviews

“Was on the vineyard for the day just walking around and popped into this shop. Out of curiosity I asked how much it would cost to get my cape cod bracelets cleaned and polished. Steve offered to do it for free! Such a kind gesture . I offered to pay him again and he respectfully declined just doing it out of the kindness of his heart. So appreciative!”

5 Superb2 Reviews

“New fresh takes on MV gear that are timeless yet on trend. Quality material that holds up after several washes. Picture below with Roger the owner. Kind sweet man. Highly recommend.”

4.6 Superb26 Reviews

“I have shopped here for years. I have no idea why I have never written a Yelp review of this shop. We have many mementos from this shop, dating back more than a decade. O this visit, we went in just to browse with little intent to buy. But we found a perfect memento of this trip, something we actually needed, a new wall clock for my husband's study. It has a topographic map of Woods Hole as the background clock face and has a frame of copper. It was not terribly expensive but is a novelty for our home and seems to be working well. The staff was incredibly informative about current goods from an artist we have bought in the past. There was some very pretty natural themed jewelry that in the past I probably would have purchased but probably do not have a real need now. I did pick up some note cards by a local artist as those are always useful. When we return to Woods Hole in the future we will undoubtedly return to this shop. We always do.”

4.6 Superb25 Reviews

“I LOVE Claudia...the store, that is. Not a year goes by that I don't purchase something from the store. At the Vineyard Haven store, the display cases appear curated. The Edgartown location, is a larger space and has several different categories of jewelry, from Estate to contemporary. Either way, there will be something that complements your style, and is of very high quality whether its crystals, beads, diamonds or semi-precious stones--Claudia's forte'.”

4.5 Superb6 Reviews

“I love visiting this shop whenever I come to the island! The owners are friendly and so, so helpful. They once helped me arrange to get a gift for my partner while keeping it a surprise. ? I am so grateful to this couple, and I truly love that I always discover something new here. Thank you!!!”

4.5 Superb12 Reviews

“They have some really neat trinkets and clothes in this shop! Definitely something you don’t see everyday! The cashiers are awesome especially Noah, they make sure you have a great shopping experience!”

4.5 Superb14 Reviews

“Excellent boho shop with sustainable brands and scented products. However, this place is slightly expensive. When in Martha’s Vineyard this is a must for women’s clothes and fragrance shopping!”

4.5 Superb15 Reviews

“The store owner was amazing. She was patient and knowledgeable about all the products carried. As the name states serenity, she seems to take pride in creating a serene environment. When another customer was talking so loudly on her phone (via speaker) that we could barely hear ourselves, she politely asked her to refrain from cellphone use. Even when the other customer became belligerent she handled the matter extremely professionally. I highly recommend this store. I could not have asked for better customer service.”

4.2 Good14 Reviews

“Timeless Treasures is an exquisite and unique shop. Gerda, the owner, focuses on the customer and her needs. She will create personal orders in your size, provide color and fabric ideas and offer suggestions to help you look Amazing! Her customer service is outstanding and the best I have ever received. Once you join the Timeless family, you will never go back. Truly a Timeless Treasure!”

4 Good11 Reviews

“My husband bought me a beautiful necklace that I have worn everyday since 2008. MV is a very special place and after years of always looking I got a special necklace. Love the artistry and unique style of the piece.Well it had the glass come apart and Cheyanne was so helpful in getting it repaired! It is back and looks so beautiful. I am so appreciative for the unique selection you provide and service.”

4.2 Good32 Reviews