-
November 2021 by Collette J.
Very disappointed. Undercooked pies. Drowning in sauces. Lack of toppings. Says mayo for BLT pizza but was sweet like miracle whip. Never again
-
December 2020 by Mackenzie S.
A staff member wasn't wearing a mask at the counter, and there was a patron inside without a mask as well. Upon coming to leave a review, I see that somebody else posted the same thing 3 months ago. I will be reporting both the convenience store and the pizza shop to the Washtenaw health department. It blows my mind that someone would refuse something as easy to do as wear a face mask. It's disrespectful to the community they profit off of.
-
September 2020 by C.W. R.
Closest I've come to a the tavern cut thin crust I was so used to in Chicago, and I really enjoyed it! Not soggy or greasy. Just a nice solid pizza! Will be my go-to going forward.
-
August 2020 by Davey S.
Went here and workers were not wearing masks and multiple patrons inside the store were not wearing masks either. No one seemed to care.
-
December 2019 by Brandon M.
Have ordered delivery from this place twice now and I have to say hands down the best pizza to get in the Ann Arbor/Ypsi area. While I do live on the other side of town from it their deliveries have been reasonably timed and quality of food has been on spot. Highly recommend Detroit style deep dish.
-
October 2019 by Amanda D.
Sitting at Townies Brewery wanting some food. They don't have a good menu but they allow you to bring in any outside food as long as you're drinking here so we ordered pizza and a sub from Buscemis next door. It's inside of a convenient store. It's a tight squeeze getting in. I realized as I was walking over that they didn't ask for a name with our order. I walked in and he asked if I had a pick up order. I said yes but they didn't ask for a name. He said "it's ok we go by voice" lol. He grabbed my order and met me at the counter to pay lol. I was alittle disappointed that the sub wasn't hot. It was cold and wrapped in plastic wrap. However, it was still good. Would have been better toasted but it was really good. The Sicilian 6 piece square pizza was really good. The crust was fluffy and crispy and airy. Very good. We would definitely come back. I wish they would put napkins in the to go order bags lol. We had no napkin and no way to cut the sub in half lol.
-
September 2019 by Ben W.
The owners are too eager to tow your car. It doesn't matter if you shop here.
-
August 2019 by Sam J.
Love this place. The food I always fresh and the service is professional and friendly. Great wine and craft beer selection. Even beer liquor selection.
-
October 2018 by Dorothy G.
I'd give them none if that was an option. Nothing like the Buscemis I had growing up around metro Detroit. No caramelized outer crust. Actually it looked like they cut off the crust on one side. The pizza pic on the plate shows the outside corner piece! Ordered double cheese which counts as two extra toppings there. Didn't even look like regular cheese. Missing cheese on center pieces, dough not cooked all the way through. The antipasto salad was a joke. A bunch of yellow lettuce, a few tomato slices, and a few pieces of meat and cheese thrown on top. I'll never go here again. EVER. Sad, ruined all my memories of a once great pizza
-
August 2018 by Jason C.
This used to be Busters West, the old owners sold the business, the new owners renovated, added kitchen for pizza and renamed it The Original Buscemis. I've been here many times and from time to time I would buy their pizza by the slice or their calzones. The only problem was that they only have two kinds of pizza that's sold by slices, so I planned ahead and called in an order. I got the large spicy Italian Detroit style and 10 piece wings. I've also tried their Pepperoni Roll and Mushroom Steak & Cheese Calzones, slices of their round and Detroit style. Well, it's not Jet's Pizza where you can get flavored crusts, but the Detroit Style pizza in itself was excellent! The pizza sauce tasted fresh, I would stick to the Detroit style... round is good, but square is much better! As for the wings, it's just fried wing dings served with dipping sauces, the sauce is not mixed into the wings. Their mushroom steak & cheese is good, I would stay away from the pepperoni roll.... inside is filled with the oil from the pepperoni. Definitely call ahead and place your order, mine was ready in 20 minutes. Between here and Jet's my heart is going to be torn!