-
March 2024 by Taylor O'Brien
Our family favorite. The food is always food & the service is friendly!
-
March 2024 by B G
Great service, somehow order got lost but they more than made it right. Some of the best pizza/sides I’ve ever had too.
-
November 2023 by lindsay kaczynski
I think this place needs to cook the burgers a bit more. Food poisoning and all
-
November 2023 by Scott Robinson
Pizza is one of them foods that we all mostly love, and we all have a favorite place to go! To me, Pappa J's is one of those places! Good pizza, fair price, and good people. Enjoy!
-
October 2023 by Adrian S. and Rob L.
Was in town for the weekend for a bachelor party. There are four pictures posted with the review because we went back twice in that single weekend.The guys wanted pizza so we picked the closest spot and oh man did we pick a winner! We ordered a couple pizzas and went to pick them up to eat back at our cabin. When we got back and opened them up, they were still steaming, cheese was melty, crust was crispy and had a nice crunch, everything you want in a pizza! I, myself, ordered a club wrap and it blew me out of my shoes. It was loaded with flavor. The side of cole slaw was probably some of the best cole slaw I've had... and from a pizzeria!? What a surprise!We were so impressed, we went back the next day for more! I can't speak on anyone else's order the second time around (they all enjoyed their food), but I got the cheeseburger deluxe with an extra patty. The burger was very impressive. The meat was cooked to order with thick juicy patties. Fries were okay, a little over cooked but it wouldn't stop me from coming back a third time.There was only one person working, a younger kid... we were a large group and he handled it like a pro. He took our order, we didn't wait very long and he was bringing out all of our food. He knocked it out of the park. That quality of service deserves a raise! Definitely would return.
-
October 2023 by Carrie Stryker
Went during lunchtime with some friends. The food was excellent, the service was top notch, and we had the place to ourselves.10/10 would recommend.Also, try the pickle pizza. Your tastebuds will have a field day!
-
October 2023 by Vicki
Excellent service, even when you go late and they are only another hour or so!! The food was delicious!! ?♥️ They are much more than just a Pizza place too!! ?♥️?????etc...
-
August 2023 by Richard Schenk
Great pizza I always get it when I’m out in that
-
August 2023 by Shawn
Mini icecream portions, pizza buffet is never stocked, wings are soggy like they are boiled.
-
August 2023 by David Lange
Old timey - out at the lake - pizza place. Great service, fresh salad. Dined in. Sunday afternoon and it’s empty but take out was busy. Get out of TC and go for a drive to a very nice place.
-
July 2023 by Eddie Johns
Delivered to Long Lake area and the pizza was great!
-
July 2023 by Andrea Henderson
Stopped here for a late lunch after getting back to mainland from South Manitou Island. Such Delicious Pizza! Good salad bar!! Appreciated that the lettuce was Leaf Lettuce and not anemic iceberg... over all my whole family was impressed! So glad we stopped here!!
-
June 2023 by N Kriegbaum
Great little diner to stop for pizza. We particularly liked the salad bar and pizza buffet. It's hard to find a salad bar these days. The pizza was steaming fresh while the salad bar had the typical offerings along with a couple cold pasta salads. Our children ordered a pepperoni pizza without sauce and it came out fairly quick and just as ordered... they loved it. Service was excellent the gentleman in charge was incredibly friendly and attentive. Extra points for the cool Pulp Fiction decor.
-
April 2023 by Martin Rizzi
100 pizzas on time every year for our men’s retreat, always quality and they even helped me reprint the receipt when I (maybe Seth?) lost it.
-
April 2023 by Michelle Kilinski
Disappointed, ordered 4 subs, none labeled, looked like they had been thrown together very sloppily, the bacon on the BLT tasted weird enough that my daughter took it off and added her own from home, then found a hair in it! :( They always used to be reliable and tasty, maybe an off night?! Unfortunate.
