Otsego Party Store maintains consistent standards and friendly service, similar to its previous ownership. The store has a small selection of items due to its size, and staffing issues have been noted, though staff remain friendly. Customers have experienced limited stock, such as only one package of hamburger buns, possibly due to high demand or waiting for shipments. Some clutter and a slightly unfriendly atmosphere were also mentioned, and prices are considered a bit high. Overall, a decent local spot with friendly staff.
The owners are friendly and personable! Daily stop on my way to work.
February 2026
GREAT PLACE AND EASY IN AND OUT. PLENTY OF PARKING AND FRIENDLY STAFF.
March 2024
Pretty okayish, they seem to have kept the same standards as the last owners. Seem to have struggled with staffing, but who isn't right now? And they're always friendly 😀
