-
March 2024 by Kyle P
Take a normal pizza, double the dough, and you have their deep dish.
-
March 2024 by Jacqueline Cruzan
When we arrived to get our order. Which was 3-16 inch chicago style deep dish pizzas we were told they were behind. This was our 1st order, but it definitely wont be our last. It was definitely more then worth the xtra wait. Best pizza in the area. Very nice people running the place also. Thank you for the great pizza. I have learned my lesson about how much to order also. But do not mind heating up, and eating the leftovers either. Very good.
-
March 2024 by Evan Mercie
The service was extremely polite. I was a bit short on the remaining change, and he said that he cover it so we don’t miss out on pizza. The pizza was really good, the mozzarella and brisket were amazing together. Never heard or thought of brisket on pizza but it is a great idea. I never write reviews but I had too, I will definitely be back again.
-
February 2024 by Logan Sehy
One of the best Chicago style deep dish pizzas I've had.
-
February 2024 by Karen Lesman
this is a hidden gem! By far the best Chicago Pizza i’ve ever eaten! Can’t wait to try everything they serve up and he is a butcher! oh my goodness!
-
February 2024 by RSROARING R
The beef sandwhich was delicious totally dry unless you order it with juice ( next time). Also ordered S,M deepdish but it felt n tasted like a cheese pizza. Order ahead early tuesday afternoon was over 2 hrs for walkins, they did say they are getting another oven soon which should help.
-
February 2024 by Mitch Farran
Outstanding chicago pie..drove from GR and highly recommend!! No more driving to chicago ? haven't tried the brisket yet but have a feeling it will be on point...definitely will be back tx
-
February 2024 by Wendi S.
A Slice of Chicago Heaven in Paw Paw, MI. We saw the MLive article about their Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza and had to try it. If you're craving an authentic taste of Chicago right here in Paw Paw, look no further than Paw Paw Country Market's Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza. From the moment you lay eyes on it, you know you're in for a treat. The crust, thick and golden-brown, provides the perfect foundation for what can only be described as a masterpiece of flavor. Each bite is a harmonious blend of gooey cheese, zesty tomato sauce, and a symphony of toppings that dance across your taste buds. The attention to detail and commitment to quality shine through in every aspect of this culinary creation. Whether you're a Windy City native missing home or a local looking to expand your pizza horizons, Paw Paw Country Market delivers an unforgettable experience that will keep you coming back for more. Highly recommended!
-
February 2024 by Toby Meisenheimer
First time here after the article dropped. Can’t believe I haven’t been here or heard of this place. Antonio and staff were very friendly and treated every customer including us like people with souls. Walked out with the heaviest two large deep dish pizzas I’ve ever carried. As defectors of Illinois I miss very little of that state except the deep dish Chicago pizzas. We have now solved that missing piece. We will be back.
-
February 2024 by patrick meine
Born and raised Chicago area and this is easily the best deep dish outside of the city I’ve had and better than a lot in the Chi. Owner is friendly too! Can’t wait to try the Chicago style thin and the Italian beef! If you’re from Chicago and missing a slice of home go here, you won’t be disappointed!
-
February 2024 by Star aaron9
HAD IT FOR THE FIRST TIME. WORTH EVERY PENNY. PECAN CAKE WAS SMOOTH TASTE
-
February 2024 by CHILIPEPPER pepper
Staying in town for a few days While my son and daughter-in-law are out of town, my son told me to go to this place For a great sandwich (Italian beef sub with hot peppers) and or Deep dish pizza for starters, food was Great Atmosphere was Great too Good People!!
-
February 2024 by Rebekah Griffith
The owner was super sweet when we went in! He ran back to double check ingredients for me when I mentioned a dairy allergy and was super conscientious of that need. Food was awesome as well. My family is from south of Chicago and this is the best Italian beef I’ve found in Michigan! Glad to have a little taste of going to Grandma’s house!
-
February 2024 by Peter A.
Ok, ok... I confess I hadn't even given this place a second glance EVERYTIME I went through Paw Paw, and then the Mlive article: I'm telling you the food was so good. Italian sandwiches with sweet and hot peppers wet...YES PLEASE! ALL DAY LONG. I will be back and I will preorder a Chicago deep dish!
-
February 2024 by R. J.
Lots of hype for Chicago deep dish pizza. Got a 16 inch deep dish with sausage, a classic first try. The toppings, sauce, and cheese were spot on for Chicago, but the crust left something to be desired. The crust wasn't flaky or buttery at all. At best the dough was bready and it worst it was bordering on that Pillsbury dough taste. A good Chicago deep dish pie should have a crust at the end that you are looking forward to eat by itself. Reading other Yelp reviews about the pizza, it doesn't seem like they are very familiar with Chicago deep dish. Don't expect a Chicago food experience for the deep dish pizza. UPDATE: The owner has now accused me of lying about my review. I'll happily share my credit card receipt with them to prove I got their pizza. I'm now sure I never will go back given the accusation of the owner. I left the review at 3 stars after this update (the original review score) because that is what the food deserves in my opinion regardless of the owner's response. If the owner could reference which Chicago pizza they are inspired by, then I could try that and compare them.
