Buffalo Nickel Antiques is a large two-story barn filled with a variety of antiques, vintage items, and crafts. The shop is beautifully decorated and offers tons of items to explore, making it easy to spend a lot of time browsing. While some visitors appreciate the wide selection and find unique treasures, others feel it leans more towards a kitschy boutique than a traditional antique store. Prices are comparable to antique shops, so shoppers should expect items to be a bit pricier. Many recommend visiting during the Christmas season for unique finds. Overall, Buffalo Nickel Antiques is a cute place to visit, but those specifically searching for true antiques may find the selection limited.
In past years, I remembered this place being much more of a treasure hunt, last few times I've visited the inventory has lacked and prices were unnecessarily high. I understand that there is an inflow and outflow to this style of business, so I'll continue to visit and hope sellers put better stuff out
April 2026
Very fun place. Plenty of treasures to look through
February 2026
This is a very shabby chicken place with lots of beautiful decor items and homemade crafts. Not sure I would classify it as an antique store, but it's worth a visit. So many unique items!
