Casey's offers a mix of experiences. The pizza is generally considered good, with some reviews praising the regular pizza as especially delicious. A customer appreciated the helpful service when they called to find a lost phone case, noting that staff went out of their way to search for it. The food options include hot foods and pizza on the warmer, though the overall food quality is described as "mid." The coffee, however, is seen as low quality, with one reviewer mentioning it as bottom shelf. Service levels vary; some find it not the best, but others praise the staff’s friendliness and dedication. Notably, a young employee on his second day made an effort to correct an order promptly, leaving a positive impression. The store’s management is also appreciated, with remarks about a manager who is viewed as a great person deserving of recognition. The location has mixed reviews, with some noting it’s not ideal for quick access due to the speed limit. Overall, the store shows potential with friendly staff and good food options, though some areas could improve.
Went out to mapleton to service brakes on my uncle's truck, swung by this caseys a couple times for lunch and when the drinks ran dry, those slushees are super refreshing. Service was fantastic, lady at the register was super friendly and helpful
April 2026
9:15 am and there’s no pizza? All I wanted was a breakfast slice. The counter guy was nice but it’s frustrating when the one thing yall brag about isn’t even available
May 2025
Food is mid but we know the regular pizza is absolutely delicious, called to see if I lost my beats phones case there and the dude who picked up the call absolutely went on a search for me. Love the service thanks so much.
