Casey's in New York Mills is a gas station and store offering quality fuels, household essentials, and groceries. It is known for its excellent pizza, made with from-scratch dough, real mozzarella, and fresh toppings. The kitchen food provides good value, and the location also has appetizers, sweet treats, and drinks. Customers report the place is clean and easy to access. The staff is consistently described as friendly, helpful, and going above and beyond.
We ordered pizza and it was ready when we got there to pick it up
April 2026
Amazing experience every time I visit! The staff is super friendly and the food never disappoints. It's my go-to spot for great coffee and delicious snacks!
