-
August 2025 by Looney Liberal
Always takes so long for a pizza
-
July 2025 by MN -NE-Man
After pizza was delivered the driver gladly accepted my generous tip and left. I discovered my pizza was folded in half and almost all the toppings were now on one side. Seems like I’m having issues every few times I order now. This place used to be the best pizza in town. Not sure what changed. It’s a gamble anymore on whether you will get a good pizza. Good luck.
-
July 2025 by Anthony Sullivan
Caseys pizza is absolutely delicious and always available by the slice!
-
June 2025 by Jason H
pizza tastes real crappy even little Caesars is 100x better
-
May 2025 by Carver Fastner
Ordered 2 pizzas and placed the order at this location by accident so we called to try and cancel it and they said they can’t cancel it so we ended up just going there to get the pizza and they said they didn’t have a order for it. This place scammed me for my money and won’t give me the pizza I paid for.
-
June 2024 by Anna Aune
I had a very lovely interaction with the lady the last time I went in. She helped me get the person who was working at the pizza station's attention to help me. She was quick, helpful, and understanding. So also nade small talk with me. The pizza itself was absolutely amazing! I had the taco pizza! It was a great choice. Overall happy with my experience and with the cashier who was helpful and sweet!
-
October 2023 by Terry Cockell
Casey's is a very nice place to go for gas and Fast Food...
-
September 2023 by ryan venske
The pizza at this location was amazing
-
August 2023 by Adam M.
Thoroughly impressed lately here. Always fresh quality pizza, and nice friendly staff. These stores are hit or miss but this one is consistent. This crew deserves a raise!! Happy customer with no complaints. Five stars.
-
August 2023 by Hotel Scootis
Hello everyone! I would like to remind you all that the concept of a review is to rate the establishment and not your visit. That’s why you only get one. Overall I’d say gas station pizza is gas station pizza, and it seems that your negative reviews show that you’ve never eaten gas station pizza. Also the place looks clean from the many times I’ve been here.
-
August 2023 by surprise
I love their candy and ice cream but most importantly pizza haha ??
-
May 2023 by Dawn Raadt
I LOVE Casey's pizza. Unfortunately my last pizza was doughy in the middle, with little sauce and cheese. Not up to your usual...
-
September 2022 by Tamera Grace
False advertising on time!!!!! Annoying
-
June 2022 by Julia Ohmann (Julz)
DO NOT order pizza from here!!!! On the last 3 occasions we've ordered from here are pizza is either made completely wrong, not cooked, under cooked, and/or mutilated in it's cutting. There are far better places to get pizza in town. Plus, the service here sucks. I have on multiple requests asked for refunds or replacements and have been either ignored or passed around from person to person. If I could give negative starts I would!!!
-
May 2022 by Karen Turner
Unfortunately, this is by far the worse pizza/wings we have had. Wrong pizza order, ordered Hawaiian and got ham. Wrong wings, ordered traditional and received burnt boneless. Got the sauces correct. They were busy, but this was a sad experience.
