Casey's is a clean and convenient stop with a good number of workers, although they can be inconsistent with tasks. The restaurant offers a variety of pizzas, including breakfast pizza, pepperoni pizza, and brisket pizza, which is a customer favorite. While there can be issues with inventory and billing, the night crew provides great customer service. Many visitors appreciate the friendly staff and the overall atmosphere. It is also a "go to" place for immediate food or gas needs, especially for those with cabins nearby. Customers enjoy the good pizza by the slice, though some have noted that the breakfast pizza per slice has too much breakfast sausage on it. The breakfast burrito is also popular, with some wishing there was a pizza pocket option. Overall, Casey's is a great place to eat with a recommended pizza menu and friendly employees, and it offers a welcoming feeling, especially for those enjoying the nearby lake.
Always excellent service and very polite. They will make a full pizza and lots of other things when you need. Calling ahead works great and they have room for my semi 😀
May 2025
Kitchen manager very kind stayed open a couple min after close time for me to get a couple things. She is awesome. I appreciate it so much.
March 2025
Have questions about the gad pumps sometimes they don't read or register the amount of fuel or swap between 87 and premium
