Casey's in Pillager is a convenient stop offering quality fuels, household essentials, and groceries. It is praised for having the best pizza, featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The food, including appetizers and sweet treats, is considered very good, with some calling it the best. The location is easy in and out with lots of parking. Staff are generally described as kind and efficient, engaging in good small talk, though one cashier was noted as not pleasant. The atmosphere is that of a standard gas station. A noted drawback is that the single restroom closes at 11pm, which is inconvenient for such a busy place.
Thank heavens they finally fixed the worst of their parking lot. I feel like the amount of business they bring in, they could have done the whole thing. Only managed to blow 1 tire from hitting one. Donuts are the best around.
June 2026
Not enough employees wait times are way to long buy the time ya get a slice of pizza and pay for it its ice cold. Need more hep there.
June 2026
Only went there for gas. This is a prepay inside station.
