Casey's in Pine City is considered by many to be the best convenience store in town, with some calling it their favorite. It offers pizza delivery and pickup featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The menu also includes appetizers, warm breakfast options, fresh doughnuts, sweet treats, and items like a grilled chicken wrap and mac 'n cheese. Coffee is noted as good. The store provides reliable service, great customer service from a cheerful staff, and stocks household essentials and groceries. Customers can also fill up with quality fuels. Some find the space a tad bit small and note that certain food items can be pricey, plain, or inconsistently prepared.
Gas was cheap and the pizzas were extremely delicious.
June 2026
I love their food. Pretty great one stop shop if you need something quick but also filling. Their new homemade ranch is also absolutely fantastic!
April 2026
Casey’s has gotten better food now and their store is clean, warm, and easy to shop in. I truthfully just use their restrooms and gas because gas is usually cheaper here.
