Stillwater Olive Oil Company is an amazing store and a gem of a resource. It offers an extensive selection of super tasty and unique olive oils, balsamics, and white vinegars in a few different sizes. Favorites include the Tuscan herb oil and the 18-year balsamic. The staff is very informative and super kind. The shop securely ships products, making them great for events like weddings. Customers love to taste test the excellent products, though building relationships with regulars could enhance the experience. It is a highly recommended stop in Stillwater.
Went in to pick up a last minute hostess gift and the employees were incredibly nice and helpful. Great olive oil and they wrapped it up nicely for us for free. Would definitely recommend!
March 2026
Really cute store with a large selection of fused/infused olive oils and vinegars. The flavors were genuinely great. They also offer travel friendly bottle sizes (2oz)
March 2026
I couldn't get to the store this round and wanted a refill of my favorite Sicilian Lemon balsamic vinegar. Whoever packed this stuff for shipping is a master at making sure things arrive safely to their destination...THANKS for taking that kind of care. My order also arrived super fast. 🙂
