Casey's is a pizza business that receives mixed reviews. Some customers report significant recent problems, including very long delivery times and poor quality control. They describe receiving pizzas that are incorrectly made, such as a hand-tossed pizza being thinner than thin crust, which suggests issues with training or consistency. These experiences lead to disappointment, especially from those who fondly remember it as a great store and a go-to for excellent pizza. However, other experiences are positive. Orders sometimes arrive perfectly, and staff can be creative and thoughtful, like labeling boxes with fun names. Employees are noted for being friendly and going above and beyond for customers, providing helpful and exceptional service that makes a big impact.
Let the phone ring for ten minutes and told me they closed at 9:24 pm when I tried to order a pizza, drove past on my way home and they were open still
August 2026
Smaller store! Hot food services workers were friendly. Pizza was good, but cheesy bread was really good. Bought two of them, well worth it.
July 2026
Ordered a pizza in advance. Plenty of time. Wasn't even started when I arrived 10 minutes past the pick up time. Waited 25 minutes for it.
