Casey's in Buffalo, MO is known for having the best pizza, featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and the freshest toppings. The pizza is made fresh with a perfect crust and a great amount of toppings. Beyond pizza, the deli offers good food like the brisket mac & cheese and pork tenderloin sandwich. The store also provides appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, groceries, and household essentials. Customers can fill up their gas tank with quality fuels. The staff is always friendly and the service is good. The store is super clean with a great selection of goods, making it a highly recommended stop.
Monday September 22nd, 2025 at 4:49pm. This was the best service we've ever received at any Casey's ever. Thank you to Madison for being super helpful.
May 2024
Love Casey's gas station! Reliable pizza and breakfast burritos!
October 2023
Staff is always friendly, selection of store goods is great & the food from deli is good. I highly recommend the brisket Mac & cheese & the pork tenderloin sandwich
