Casey's in Eldon, MO, located at 224 W 4th St, is known for its made-from-scratch pizza featuring real mozzarella cheese and fresh toppings. The menu also includes appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and essential groceries, making it a convenient stop for various needs. Customers appreciate the friendly staff, particularly one employee who consistently provides excellent service. However, there have been complaints about inconsistent pizza quality and long wait times. Some customers reported receiving undercooked pizzas or missing key ingredients in specialty orders. Instances of poor communication regarding order status and delays have led to frustration, with some customers feeling ignored when they raised concerns. Despite these issues, many still enjoy the convenience of Casey's and find the overall experience positive. Improvements in order accuracy and timely service could enhance customer satisfaction.
Spectacular customer service from Steven. Went above and beyond
March 2025
Normally the pizza here is pretty good, but today was an exception pizza was undercooked over sauced.Just soggy, wasn't worth spending the money.
January 2025
I like this location better than the Lake location. It's always nice to come into a place where the staff are friendly. I always have a great experience with Stephanie she is always very friendly and seems to care about the customers.
