-
August 2025 by Vickie Nash
Took a 90 minutes to get the pizza and it was missing toppings and burnt
-
April 2025 by Vicki Smith
This is the second time I have preordered a pizza and went in to pick it up and they had not even started it yet.
-
October 2024 by Gerald Otto
Typical gas station variety store good for gas coffee and a quick snack. Pizza sandwich cookie drinks nothing special or different here but dependable needs longer evening hours till 2 am would be good.
-
April 2024 by Roger Wm Pfeiffer
Did not get to try pizza, but still had good food!
-
September 2023 by Jodi Jones
Parking: Close parking to the store
-
June 2023 by Thomas Price
Usually get pizza or gas. It’s hit or miss with the quality of the food. Sometimes it’s hit and fresh sometimes not. Even when ordering on app. I usually order from Mansfield .Customer service goes the same way.Just your standard Casey’s
-
March 2023 by CJ Todd
Order pizza there often and everytime i go in, “it’s going to be another 30 minutes” and then it’s still not even made by then.
-
August 2022 by Jessie Anderson
This is the 2nd Monday in a row that we went in too get coffee and it was OFF AND COLD AND YOUR WORKERS DONE NOTHING ABOUT it LIKE USUAL
-
August 2022 by Mike Johnson
Been going there for two months now. Been seeing many changes and they are for the worst. Lost several good employees to a different store because they were offered two dollars more an hour. Went in today and the employees there are not trained very well at all and no manager to help them out. Bought two apple fritters and could not find that button on the register and charged me for something more expensive. This store ran off a good manager and several good employees and traded them for an untrained and unfriendly staff. Might have to drive to another store to get the rights prices and the friendliness that is the life blood of Casey’s stores or go to the other store in Hartville where crappy service is expected. Maybe we should boycott this Casey’s till they get there crap straightened out. Go to Double Eagle or The Trading Post in Hartville MO.
-
February 2022 by Russell Kelley
Ordered pizza 3 times in a month and anything from wrong order to forgot to put it in the oven. Probably due to them outside smoking with their friends. Looks like a Crack house
-
February 2022 by Russell K.
Caseys in Hartville Mo has turned into a trash hole. We've ordered pizza there 3 times in last month and order was wrong, forgot to start it, or didn't see the online order, probably because they are outside smoking and hanging out with druggie looking people. The managers are no better.
-
February 2022 by Mary Braswell
I bought pizza from here last night. I buy pizzas from caseys often. But this is the 1st time in Hartville.This was the worst pizza I have ate. The crust was soggy and wasn't done. It was gross. I had to put it in the I oven just so we could eat some. I will never ever buy from this store again . I bought 2 pizzas now we have to cook more. Mansfield and moutain grove I have never had this problem. More training for this store.
-
June 2021 by Katy Kareus
I live in Hartville and its daily I stop in this location whether it be gas or coffee. For the last 5 days coffee has been scarce and or cold. I realize the store itself is busy but I wont be back until y'all learn how to keep coffee station hot and rolling. Oh and when I do nicely request for a new fresh pot of coffee to be made that the employee not sigh in exasperation with rolling eyes where me the customer can hear you. Learn some manners!
-
June 2021 by Katy K.
If you want cold coffee come to Hartville Casey's where the coffee is cold and the employees just don't care.
-
May 2021 by Lil Lost 2
Some days are better just depends on who's working I guess. But it's a gas station and pizza place!
