-
August 2025 by Dustin Heddens
I’ve eaten a lot of Casey’s pizza in my life and this one was by far the worst. Whoever was making pizzas 8/29/25 around 8pm needs to find a new line of work. I normally defend Casey’s pizza but this was definitely ‘gas station pizza’
-
June 2025 by Jaymee Burton
Stopped in for a brisket pizza with pineapple, was ready in 10 mins and it was delicious. Never ordered here before but the fella in the kitchen was very friendly and made it easy.
-
June 2025 by Jill Herring
Dirty store. No one at counter. Bathroom was gross. Smells like old grease in there.
-
April 2025 by Krysta Geisler
The young man working behind the counter needs to stop asking every customer if they believe in Jesus. There are other religions, besides Christianity and it made me very uncomfortable.
-
December 2024 by Dorian
A young guy who works behind the counter is so rude and unhelpful. He couldn't be bothered to get up and help me when I entered and was spitting something into a cup behind the counter. 🤢 Absolutely disgusting. The app didn't have the actual food options for ordering ahead and they were out of several things.
Moral of the story: Drive down the road to Rhodes. Way better and friendlier, too.
-
September 2024 by Amanda Yount
Went into caseys this morning had one guy checking out and the other three was outside smoking no pizza was made actually they really didn't have no breakfast but yet three of the employees were out smoking we will NOT be back. It's Casey's in fruitland.
-
February 2024 by Hope Kilburn
I got gasoline and the cashier in there was very kind I didn’t have enough money on my card and I had to go to my car to get cash and he paid the difference out of his own pocket and I went back in to pay and they said he did already but car didn’t take all the money for gas so hopefully he got his money back thank you for your kindness but I didn’t get his name he was young and very kind ….
-
February 2024 by Lee Wills
You don't get a hello when you walk in you go to the register they scan it they ask you if you have a rewards but they won't tell you your total they walk away they don't even stand at the register when your thing go through you don't know they don't say goodbye I have a good day or anything The worst customer service experience I ever had never had it with nobody ever said anything.
-
January 2024 by Beth Richardt
Store dirty and dolly in bad place almost hit it while walking to bathroom. No pizza made and we have been waiting for almost 15 mins. Very unprofessional and unorganized.
-
December 2023 by Ron Crawford
I love me someCASEY'S!!!
-
August 2023 by andrew jacobson
Friendly Service
-
July 2023 by DuckieR11
Good atmosphere, nice employees
-
July 2023 by Darlene Bradley
Always friendly
-
November 2022 by Annette Lisa Door
This is a great place to get Pizza and various hot foods. I personally ❤ their glazed donuts. I'm addicted to them! The reason only 4 stars is simply the state of their ladies restroom. Several times when I visited store and went to use their restroom, it had a vary funky smell to it and toilet paper and paper towel trash bin had overflowed and the mess was all over the floor, and the sink was not looking too inviting you wash your hands in. Other than that, store is clean and organized with fast checkout.
-
March 2022 by Aaron F. Stone
The interstate sign said it was 24 hrs, and it was closed at 9:00 PM.
