Casey's on Eastland Drive in Jefferson City is known for its excellent pizza delivery and pickup. The pizza features made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and the freshest toppings. Customers also praise the great food, including appetizers and sweet treats. The staff is consistently described as the nicest, friendliest, most kind, helpful, and customer-friendly in the city, with specific compliments for the pizza makers. They are efficient even when busy and go above and beyond to correct any order issues. The store is always clean and well-stocked. While most experiences are positive, there have been rare instances where a special request for how the pizza is cut was not followed. Many customers visit daily and state it is always worth it.
I’m here all the time. I frickin love me some Casey’s
August 2026
Both pizzas were decent the only issue is the dough was on the undercooked side they definitely could have been cooked longer which is something that needs to be addressed other than that haven’t had any issues with any of the food that has been ordered here it’s a great gas station location.
May 2026
Staff are FRIENDLY and attentive despite this Casey's is one of the busiest in Jefferson City.
