-
March 2023 by Dale Davis
John is very knowledgeable and very fair. He will evaluate every coin and offer Grey sheet prices with no obligation to sell. I would recommend calling in advance if you have a collection to give him enough time to be accurate on the prices.
-
January 2023 by Ken Stclair
Very nice man....I had just a small item to sell but he took the time to help me. I would definitely go back.
-
December 2022 by Mary Brann
I should have left this review months ago but I figured better late than never. I had the pleasure of visiting this coin store twice during the past yr. The last time I stopped by, I was purchasing some of the classic Whitman folders for my son, who’d shown an interest in coin collecting. The owner was extremely patient, answered all of my questions. Before I left, he asked me the year my son was born & after telling him, he gave me a mint set of coins from that year, as a gift to my son! Such customer service is a rarity these days & I genuinely appreciated it.
-
November 2022 by Melissa Scarborough
Very fair and nice gentleman. He knows his stuff and is very helpful.
-
October 2022 by Roxxy Doxxy
I was looking for a coin dealer to look at some coins I had and ran across this place. I'm glad i did. John is kind, friendly, and very smart. When it comes to coins or anything,he knows his stuff. He takes the time to explain and educate you about what you have. I highly recommend American Rare Coin. If your looking for a place to buy or sell coins or jewelry, then this is the place. You won't be disappointed.
-
October 2022 by Lynn Polston
I had a very good experience here selling coins. Highly recommend!
-
October 2022 by Zanyla Norles
This man was absolutely prejudice. We were trying different locations with a rare coin we had. We received lots of great feed back prior from other locations. Seems this location couldn’t afford to pay anything so he assume it was a fake coin. But we had already prior been other places! Was told don’t go here. They were absolutely right. The older man seem very judgmental immediately telling me our coin was fake and didn’t wanna accept our coin because we feel that were African decent.
-
October 2022 by Dylan Kennett
John was just awesome. He took the time to look at what I brought in when others wouldn't and he was just an absolute delight to talk to. He worked with me and I was very satisfied. I will be recommending him to everyone I know.
-
September 2022 by Neal P.
John is a Pleasure To Deal with! Best place to sell Your Silver very fai easy to deal with. Has great Coins! This is my Coin Shop! THANK YOU John! Sincerely Neal thanks again
-
May 2022 by John Diederich
John was extremely professional, friendly, and knowledgeable. I brought in dozens of old coins and he offered me a very fair price, explaining his rationale along the way. I could not be more pleased!
-
May 2022 by J Williams
I have been several times now and will agree, John is very fair and indeed knows his stuff. I've learned something new every time. If I win the lotto I'll buy yhe store up.
-
April 2022 by Jordan Kerfeld
John absolutely knows his stuff. I had such a pleasant experience with him today and here is my experience: he matches closely the value of particular items and acts accordingly (I called him and told him what I had, he told me he was expecting a rise in price within an hour, and his payout reflected that when I came to him in person less than an hour later! How great is that?). He is in a position to teach if one has the desire, and taught me a lot going forward in my hobby.He gives honest, great rates and I plan to work with him in the future. Character and integrity mean a lot and John fits the bill. Highly recommend him, and hope to work with him again soon.
-
April 2022 by Maura Rios
John was very helpful to myself and my father. He knows the business helped us understand what we had and how to move forward. He took my call after hours and was also very patient with my elderly father when we came into his place of business. My dad had also sold to him a year or so ago and found his prices to be fair. I can’t thank John enough for his help, fairness, knowledge and time.
-
January 2022 by Tayler Delzell Vance
John was very easy to work with. I called and got his price beforehand, then was in and out in less than 5 minutes. I will definitely be doing business there again.
-
August 2021 by Brian Lahmeyer
John is a great person to business with! very fair on his pricing and very knowledgeable in his field of business. I've purchased from him on and off for the last 20 years and never any issues here!
