Casey's in Liberty, MO, offers a wide range of products including pizza, appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, groceries, and fuel. Known for its pizza made from scratch with real mozzarella cheese and fresh toppings, it provides a satisfying meal option for customers. The store is generally clean and well-maintained, and the staff is consistently polite and helpful, often going out of their way to assist customers. Despite being short-staffed at times, the team works hard to serve customers efficiently, with some staff members showing extra kindness and effort, especially during busy times. The new location shows promise, and the store has potential to be even better with more staff support. Customers appreciate the convenience of the store, especially for quick food and fuel needs. The staff’s helpfulness extends beyond typical service, with examples like giving free treats and providing water when needed. While the store can experience busy periods and occasional shortages of warm food, the quality of the pizza and friendly service make it a popular choice. Overall, Casey’s is a reliable spot for good pizza, friendly service, and essential shopping needs, with a welcoming atmosphere and potential for continued improvement.
You started out strong, but if you want to sell pizza, you have to have pizza in the rack at lunchtime. 2 times in the last 4 days, no pizza ready. People, me included, will stop coming there for lunch if you can't have product ready to buy. Edit: 01/19/26, 12:45 pm, no pizza in rack again.
January 2026
Unfortunate that their team didn’t clearly and improperly interact with the DoorDash driver to give him the Pizza I waited 65 minutes for only for them to show up with two cokes.
December 2025
This sloppy pizza was undercooked like these people didn't care. Floppy crust butt! Care about your process. Don't do customers like this! Learn from nothing Brighton Casey's by the theater, they do pizza right. This Casey's don't care!! And it shows.
