-
February 2024 by Ashton Ratterree
Doesn’t even deserve 1 star. This place is an absolute joke. The people that work here don’t care about service. Can’t even answer the phone.
-
September 2023 by Scott Ford (Scott Exploring)
Got single slice pizza from here several times, always very good... Great food and very friendly staff, I recommended it..
-
July 2023 by Jeremey K.
Bad costumer service from management. I feel bad for the staff. Food is questionable for several years now. And the store smells of mold. Get your gas but skip the prepared food. Scratch that. Breakfast is usually okay. As long as the older gentleman is working. Pizza was good for a while now I've seen undercooked dough and nothing in the warmer. Pictures to come.
-
July 2023 by Debra Rawls
We're from out of state and we were trying to find something to eat and Casey's popped up so we tried this place and the Pizza was Amazing and the cheese bread was great. The two ladies that was working last night was awesome very nice and Friendly. We give Casey's A++++++++++++++++Kid-friendliness: I would recommend thisplace to anyone who asked
-
May 2023 by Renae Clark-weatherly
The cook was very nice and polite. Thank you for your service.
-
October 2022 by Dane P
My wife worked there she has now quit because of the manger downgrading her talking bad about her in front of customers !!!! This place is a joke unclean rude people i dont recommend going there
-
September 2022 by dawn stroup
Tough crustAsked for square slice get 6 slices insteadI keep hoping it will get better and it doesn't...shame on me for expecting better
-
September 2022 by David Terry
I've been waiting over two hours on three pizza's. Hands down the worst experience ever!!
-
August 2022 by Nathaniel Oster
They advertise one price, then charge you for another. Show the manager and am told all she can do would be take down the sign. Just keep lying to customers. I'll not come here again.Update: A day, two at the most, after being notified of the response to this review by Casey's (Owner) I sent them a message via the link that was posted. A week later and nothing. This location will lie to you in order to get an extra "dime" of your money, and there is no follow-through by Casey's (Owner).
-
July 2022 by Samantha Weber
I ordered two speciality pizzas online. I added extras. Payment was done online. I go and pickup my order. I didn't look at the pizza till at home. The pizza were not cut as ordered nor did they have the extras I had ordered. Called Casey's. Got told they ran out of pepperoni. I had to ask for a refund for what I had ordered. I was told they would call back with info on how to get my refund. Not impressed. Pizza wasn't done in the middle either. Salem Casey's is much better. I guess my expectations were to high.
-
July 2022 by Joshua White
Opens at 5 is a joke. Was there at 6 and the door was locked with an employee standing behind the register stocking cigarettes. Never stopping here again for food when going fishing.
-
January 2022 by Betty Giller
I just love the donuts,I think they should make more cream filled bc there never is any..lolIt is a pretty good place.
-
October 2021 by Teresa Johnson
We ordered a large Supreme pizza this evening for a fast supper. We were told about 30 mins. Our pizza was done timely and absolutely awesome tonight. I worked at the Licking Casey's once and it was made exactly the way it should be. Thank you. I called and told them how pleased we were. I have had alot of no so good experiences there in the last year. But this was great.
-
September 2021 by RICK SANCHEZ
Walked inside to ask where the restroom was no one answered. Waited 10-15mins still no one. Walked out to my vehicle to find employees enjoying a smoke break on the side of the building w/no one inside the building. Pathetic, will be stopping at Sinclair from now on, when I'm going fishing.
-
July 2021 by Zombie Mace
It says they close at 10 but, takeout stated 10:30. Went there at 10:20 to get a little something to eat but the door was locked and no body was in there.
